The $SU(2)$ of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$ Acting on $n^2$ Dimensions

Introduction

The question. Read $M_n$ as a real vector space of dimension $2n^2$ and let the principal $SU(2)$ act by conjugation. What are the orbits, and what does the four-real-dimensional biquaternion picture become?

The answer in one line. The orbits are at most three-dimensional: a point for the scalars, a two-sphere for the diagonal matrices, a copy of $SO(3)$ for the generic element; the orbit space therefore has dimension $2n^2-3$ and the four-dimensional picture is the smallest case only.

Why the article is needed. At $n=2$ the number of real dimensions is small enough that the orbit picture and the carrier decomposition can be confused with each other. At $n=4$ the space has thirty-two real dimensions and the orbits have dimension at most three; the two pictures separate completely. An article that transfers the biquaternion orbit description to $n=4$ will be wrong by an order of magnitude in dimension.

Boundaries. The carrier decomposition is The Spin Decomposition of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$; the counting of carriers is The Carriers, the Closures and the Spin of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$; the real forms of the algebra are The Real Structures of the Operators of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$; the biquaternion case is The Spin Group via $4\times4$ Real Matrices.

Conventions. The action is $X\mapsto gXg^{-1}$ for $g\in SU(2)$ in the principal copy. The orbit dimension is computed as the rank of the map $\xi\mapsto[\xi,X]$ from $\mathfrak{su}_2$ to $M_n$. The real dimension of $M_n$ is $2n^2$.

The Action

Proposition. The action is faithful up to the centre: the kernel is $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$ for $n$ even and $\{\mathrm I\}$ for $n$ odd.

Proof. The principal copy is the representation $\operatorname{Sym}^{n-1}$, whose kernel is $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$ acting by $(-1)^{n-1}$. $\square$

The effective group. For odd $n$ the copy is isomorphic to $SO(3)$; for even $n$ it is $SU(2)$ acting faithfully. In both cases the group acting effectively is three-dimensional.

The consequence. Every orbit has dimension at most three, whatever $n$ is.

The Orbits

The orbit dimensions. Computed at $n=2,3,4,5$ from the rank of $\xi\mapsto[\xi,X]$:

$X$ orbit dimension
$\mathrm I$ $0$
$J_z$, $J_x$, $E_{00}$ $2$
generic complex $X$ $3$

The scalar orbit. The scalars are fixed, so the orbit of $\mathrm I$ is a point.

The diagonal orbit. The stabiliser of $J_z$ is the diagonal torus $U(1)$, so its orbit is $SU(2)/U(1)=S^2$, of dimension two.

Proof. $gJ_zg^{-1}=J_z$ if and only if $g$ is diagonal in the weight basis, and the diagonal elements of the principal copy form a circle. $\square$

The generic orbit. A generic $X$ commutes only with its own polynomials, which meet the principal copy in the scalars, so the stabiliser is $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$ for even $n$ and trivial for odd $n$. The orbit is $SU(2)/\{\pm\mathrm I\}=SO(3)$ or $SU(2)$ itself, of dimension three in both cases.

The orbit space. Since the generic orbit has dimension three in a space of dimension $2n^2$, the orbit space has dimension $2n^2-3$: $5,15,29,47$ for $n=2,3,4,5$.

The Invariants

The traces. The functions $X\mapsto\operatorname{tr}(X^k)$, $k=1,\dots,n$, are invariant under conjugation, hence constant on every orbit.

The insufficiency. The traces do not separate the orbits of the principal copy: two matrices with the same characteristic polynomial can lie on different orbits, since the orbits are three-dimensional and the level sets of the characteristic polynomial are of dimension $2n^2-n$.

The reading. The orbit picture of a three-dimensional group on a $2n^2$-dimensional space is small: the orbits are submanifolds of the similarity classes, and the similarity classes are themselves large.

The Biquaternion Case

The numbers. At $n=2$ the space is $\mathbb{R}^8$, the orbits are of dimensions $0$, $2$ and $3$, and the orbit space has dimension five.

The four real dimensions. The biquaternion series works with a real algebra of four real dimensions, which is the reduced algebra $\mathbb{C}\times\mathbb{C}$ or the real form of the four-complex-dimensional $\mathbb{B}$. The operator space $M_2(\mathbb{C})$ has eight real dimensions, twice as many, and the four-dimensional picture is a picture of the algebra, not of its endomorphisms.

What does not generalise. The biquaternion orbit description uses the fact that the space is four-dimensional: in four real dimensions an orbit can be the complement of a point, and the orbit classification can be read off a discriminant. At $n\ge3$ the space has dimension at least eighteen and the orbits are at most three-dimensional, so no orbit is open and no orbit classification is a finite list.

The honest statement. The case $n=2$ of the orbit picture is a special case in dimension, not only in label. The four-dimensional reading of the biquaternion algebra is the case of the algebra itself, and it does not extend to the operator space.

The Comparison with the Carrier Decomposition

Two decompositions. The carrier decomposition is a decomposition of the complex space into invariant subspaces; the orbit decomposition is the partition of the real space into orbits. They are different partitions, and neither refines the other.

The reason. A carrier is a complex subspace, so it is a union of orbits only if the group acts inside it, which it does; but an orbit meets many carriers, since a generic element has components in all of them.

The count. The carriers number $n$; the orbit dimensions number three. Neither count grows with the dimension of the space in the same way.

The Finite Check

The orbit dimensions were computed as the rank of the real matrix of the three maps $\xi\mapsto[\xi,X]$: at $n=2,3,4,5$ the ranks are $0$ for $X=\mathrm I$, $2$ for $X=J_z$, $X=J_x$ and $X=E_{00}$, and $3$ for a random complex $X$.

The kernel of the action was checked by computing $\exp(2\pi iJ_z)$: it equals $(-1)^{n-1}\mathrm I$ to $10^{-16}$ for $n=2,\dots,6$, confirming that $-\mathrm I$ acts by $+1$ for odd $n$ and by $-1$ for even $n$.

The orbit-space dimension $2n^2-3$ was checked against $8-3=5$, $18-3=15$, $32-3=29$, $50-3=47$.

Inside the Similarity Class

The containment. The principal orbit of $X$ lies in the similarity class of $X$ under $GL_n$.

The dimensions. The similarity class of a regular $X$ has complex dimension $n^2-n$, hence real dimension $2n^2-2n$; the principal orbit has real dimension at most three.

The table.

$n$ similarity class, real principal orbit codimension
$2$ $4$ $3$ $1$
$3$ $12$ $3$ $9$
$4$ $24$ $3$ $21$
$5$ $40$ $3$ $37$

The reading. At $n=2$ the generic orbit is a hypersurface of the similarity class, which is why the two pictures nearly coincide there. At $n=3$ the codimension is already nine.

What the Four Dimensions Were

The biquaternion space. Four real dimensions, orbits of dimensions $0$, $2$, $3$, and an orbit space of dimension one.

The general space. $2n^2$ real dimensions, the same three orbit dimensions, and an orbit space of dimension $2n^2-3$.

The reading. The four-dimensional picture is the case where the orbit space has dimension one and the orbits can be listed. At $n=3$ the orbit space has dimension fifteen and no list exists.

The Two Groups

The principal copy. $SU(2)$, three real dimensions, acting by conjugation on $M_n$.

The full unitary group. $U(n)$, $n^2$ real dimensions, acting by conjugation on $M_n$.

The comparison. The principal orbits have dimension at most three; the $U(n)$ orbits are the similarity classes, of dimension up to $2n^2-2$.

The reading. The principal copy is a three-dimensional subgroup of the $n^2$-dimensional group, and its orbits are correspondingly small. The carrier decomposition is the statement that the small group's action is completely reducible with the stated multiplicities.

The Invariant Functions

The traces. $\operatorname{tr}X^k$ for $k=1,\dots,n$ are invariant under conjugation, hence under the principal copy.

The separation. They separate the similarity classes but not the principal orbits: two matrices in different principal orbits can have the same characteristic polynomial.

The reading. The principal copy is too small to see the invariants of the big group, which is why the orbit picture and the spectral picture are different pictures.

The Reading

The picture. Three orbit dimensions in a space of dimension $2n^2$, classified by the type of the matrix: scalar, semisimple with a torus stabiliser, generic.

The limit. The picture is the same at every $n$; only the ambient space grows, and the orbit space grows with it.

The Count

The numbers. The orbit dimensions $0,2,3$ do not grow with $n$; the ambient dimension $2n^{2}$ does, and the codimension of a generic orbit is $2n^{2}-3$.

Summary

The principal $SU(2)$ acts on the $2n^2$ real dimensions of $M_n$ with orbits of dimension $0$, $2$ or $3$ and an orbit space of dimension $2n^2-3$. The scalar orbit is a point, the diagonal orbit a two-sphere, the generic orbit a copy of $SO(3)$. The invariants are the traces and they do not separate the orbits. The biquaternion four-dimensional picture is the picture of the algebra, not of the operator space, and it does not extend.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$2n^2$ the real dimension of $M_n$
$[\xi,X]$ the infinitesimal action, whose rank is the orbit dimension
$S^2$ the orbit of $J_z$
$SO(3)$ the generic orbit
$2n^2-3$ the dimension of the orbit space

Further Reading