The Odd Rows: $M_3(\mathbb{C})$ and $M_5(\mathbb{C})$

Introduction

The question. The rows $n=3$ and $n=5$ differ from $n=2$ and $n=4$ in the parity of the module's label. What exactly changes, and what does it change?

The answer in one line. For odd $n$ the element $-\mathrm I$ acts trivially on $\operatorname{Sym}^{n-1}$, so the copy factors through $SO(3)$, every label in the picture is an integer, and no half-integer exists anywhere.

Why the article is needed. The rows $n=2$ and $n=4$ are the spinorial rows, and they are the ones the biquaternion series and its first generalisation treat. The rows $n=3$ and $n=5$ are tensorial, and their tables are short enough to write in full. Without them the reader has no example in which the half-integer is absent by construction, and the parity of $n$ looks like a technicality rather than a structural split.

Boundaries. The decomposition is The Spin Decomposition of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$; the labels are Where the Half-Integers Go in $M_n(\mathbb{C})$; the even rows are The Spin Content of $M_4(\mathbb{C})$; the carrier tables are The Carriers, the Closures and the Spin of $M_n(\mathbb{C})$.

Conventions. $j=\tfrac{n-1}{2}$, so $j=1$ at $n=3$ and $j=2$ at $n=5$. The weights of the module are $-j,\dots,j$.

The Parity

Proposition. The image of $-\mathrm I$ in the principal copy is $(-1)^{n-1}\mathrm I$. It is $+\mathrm I$ for odd $n$ and $-\mathrm I$ for even $n$.

Proof. $-\mathrm I=\exp(2\pi iJ_z)$ in $SU(2)$, and on $\operatorname{Sym}^{n-1}$ the element $J_z$ has eigenvalues $j,j-1,\dots,-j$, so the exponential acts by $\exp(2\pi i m)$ on the weight $m$. Every weight is a half-integer, so each exponential is $\pm1$, and the product of the signs is $(-1)^{2j}=(-1)^{n-1}$. $\square$

The consequence for the group. For odd $n$ the copy is a quotient of $SU(2)$ by $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$, hence is $SO(3)$, and the module is a representation of $SO(3)$: it is tensorial.

The consequence for the labels. Every weight of the module and of the algebra is an integer for odd $n$, hence every carrier label is an integer, hence the list of labels is the same list as the list of dimensions up to the shift by one.

The check. $\exp(2\pi iJ_z)$ equals $(-1)^{n-1}\mathrm I$ to $10^{-16}$ for $n=2,\dots,6$, computed from the weight diagonal.

The Row $n=3$

The carriers. $M_3=V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0$, of dimensions $5+3+1=9$.

The module. $\mathbb{C}^3=V_1$: the defining module has spin one, an integer.

The coincidence. At $n=3$ the module's carrier and the adjoint carrier are the same, both $V_1$. The two roles that were distinct at $n=2$ and at $n=4$ coincide here, and they coincide for the same reason: the module has dimension three and the adjoint has dimension three.

The weights. The module has weights $-1,0,1$; the algebra has weights $-2,-1,0,1,2$ with multiplicities $1,2,3,2,1$.

The Casimir. The values are $0,2,6$ on $V_0,V_1,V_2$, and their sum with multiplicities is $1\cdot0+3\cdot2+5\cdot6=36$, which is $\tfrac{n^2(n^2-1)}{2}=\tfrac{9\cdot8}{2}=36$.

The Row $n=5$

The carriers. $M_5=V_4\oplus V_3\oplus V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0$, of dimensions $9+7+5+3+1=25$.

The module. $\mathbb{C}^5=V_2$: the defining module has spin two.

The position of the module's carrier. $V_2$ is the middle carrier of the five. It is neither the adjoint nor the top: the adjoint is $V_1$ and the top is $V_4$.

The weights. The module has weights $-2,-1,0,1,2$; the algebra has the differences, with multiplicities $1,2,3,4,5,4,3,2,1$.

The Casimir. The values are $0,2,6,12,20$, and the weighted sum is $1\cdot0+3\cdot2+5\cdot6+7\cdot12+9\cdot20=300=\tfrac{25\cdot24}{2}$.

The Even Rows for Contrast

The row $n=2$. $M_2=V_1\oplus V_0=3+1=4$, module $V_{1/2}$: the module's carrier is not a summand of the algebra, and $-\mathrm I$ acts by $-1$.

The row $n=4$. $M_4=V_3\oplus V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0=7+5+3+1=16$, module $V_{3/2}$: again the module's carrier is absent, and $-\mathrm I$ acts by $-1$.

The row $n=6$. $M_6=V_5\oplus\dots\oplus V_0=11+9+7+5+3+1=36$, module $V_{5/2}$.

The pattern. For even $n$ the module's label is a half-integer, $-\mathrm I$ acts by $-1$, the copy is faithful, and the module is spinorial. For odd $n$ the label is an integer, $-\mathrm I$ acts trivially, the copy factors through $SO(3)$, and the module is tensorial.

What the Odd Rows Show

No half-integer anywhere. In the odd rows every weight, every label and every Casimir value is an integer. A reader who has seen only $n=2$ and $n=4$ may believe the half-integer is intrinsic to the construction; the odd rows show that it is a parity phenomenon.

The module inside the algebra. For odd $n$ the module's carrier $V_j$ is a summand of $M_n$: $V_1$ at $n=3$, $V_2$ at $n=5$. The module and the algebra share a carrier type exactly in the odd rows.

The absent phenomenon. There is no "$-\mathrm I$ acts by $-1$" statement, no double cover, and no spinorial module. The price is that the top carrier is even: the top label is $n-1$, which is even for odd $n$.

The reading. Parity of $n$ decides between the tensorial and the spinorial picture, and it decides it at the level of the group, before any label is assigned.

The Finite Check

Computed for $n=2,\dots,6$: $\exp(2\pi iJ_z)=(-1)^{n-1}\mathrm I$ with residual below $10^{-15}$.

The carrier dimensions were read from the Casimir eigenspaces: $1,3,5$ at $n=3$ and $1,3,5,7,9$ at $n=5$, summing to $9$ and $25$. The Casimir values are $0,2,6$ and $0,2,6,12,20$, and the weighted sums are $36$ and $300$, equal to $\tfrac{n^2(n^2-1)}{2}$ in both cases.

The weight multiplicities were computed from $\operatorname{ad}_{J_z}$: at $n=3$ they are $1,2,3,2,1$ and at $n=5$ they are $1,2,3,4,5,4,3,2,1$, matching $n-\lvert d\rvert$.

The Casimir Table for the Odd Rows

$n$ values multiplicities weighted sum
$3$ $0,2,6$ $1,3,5$ $36$
$5$ $0,2,6,12,20$ $1,3,5,7,9$ $300$

The parity of the values. For odd $n$ every label is an integer, so every Casimir value $k(k+1)$ is even. For even $n$ the module's label is a half-integer, and the values $\tfrac34,\tfrac{15}{4},\dots$ of the module never appear in the algebra.

The reading. The Casimir values of the algebra are even integers at every $n$; the half-integer labels show up only as the fraction $\tfrac34$-type values of the module, which the algebra does not contain.

What the Odd Rows Cannot Show

The absence. No spinorial module, no double cover, and no element acting by $-1$ on the module.

The price. The top carrier has even spin $n-1$, so the algebra's spin is never half-integer in the odd rows, and the module's carrier is a summand.

The reading. A reader who wants to see the half-integer mechanism must go to $n=4$; a reader who wants to see its absence has $n=3$ and $n=5$.

The Two Rows in One Line

The row $n=3$. $M_3=V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0=5+3+1$, module $V_1$, group $SO(3)$.

The row $n=5$. $M_5=V_4\oplus V_3\oplus V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0=9+7+5+3+1$, module $V_2$, group $SO(3)$.

The pattern. The top carrier is $V_{n-1}$, the module is $V_{(n-1)/2}$, and the module's carrier sits in the middle of the list.

The reading. The odd rows are the rows in which the whole picture is a picture of $SO(3)$ representations, and the module is one of the carriers.

The Two Actions

At $n=3$. The module $\mathbb{C}^3$ is the vector representation of $SO(3)$, and the algebra is $V_2\oplus V_1\oplus V_0$, the traceless symmetric plus the adjoint plus the scalars.

At $n=5$. The module $\mathbb{C}^5$ is the spin-two representation of $SO(3)$, and the algebra runs from spin four down to spin zero.

The reading. In both rows the module is one of the carriers, and the highest carrier is twice the module's label.

The Module as a Carrier

The statement. For odd $n$ the module's carrier $V_j$ is a summand of the algebra, so the module is a direct summand of the algebra as a module.

The consequence. The module is visible from inside the algebra at odd $n$ and from outside at even $n$.

The reading. The difference between the odd and even rows is the difference between a module that sits inside the algebra and one that does not.

The Reading of the Two Rows

The summary line. $M_3$ has three carriers and $M_5$ has five, and in both cases the module is one of them.

The contrast with $M_4$. $M_4$ has four carriers and the module $V_{3/2}$ is not among them, so one of the four rows of the family behaves differently from the other three at the level of the module.

The reading. The odd rows are the rows in which the algebra and the module live in the same list.

Summary

For odd $n$ the principal copy factors through $SO(3)$, every label is an integer, and the module's carrier is a summand of the algebra. The rows $n=3$ and $n=5$ have carrier lists $5+3+1$ and $9+7+5+3+1$, module labels $1$ and $2$, and Casimir spectra $0,2,6$ and $0,2,6,12,20$. The even rows have half-integer module labels, the faithful copy, and no module carrier inside the algebra.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$(-1)^{n-1}$ the image of $-\mathrm I$ in the principal copy
$5+3+1$ the carrier dimensions at $n=3$
$9+7+5+3+1$ the carrier dimensions at $n=5$
$V_1$, $V_2$ the module's carriers at $n=3$, $n=5$
$36$, $300$ the weighted Casimir sums, equal to $\tfrac{n^2(n^2-1)}{2}$

Further Reading