The Reduced Norm and Spectral Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra

Introduction

The split-biquaternion algebra $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ carries two quadratic conditions on one element. The reduced norm $\Delta(\tilde Q)=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2$ is real, non-negative, multiplicative, and vanishes exactly when a half vanishes. The component invariants $|\vec q_\pm|^2$ are the squared lengths of the two vector parts; each vanishes exactly when its half is scalar. The first decides invertibility, the second detects scalar halves. The spectrum is regular when the reduced characteristic polynomial has no repeated root.

This article compares these invariants. Spectral regularity forces $\Delta\neq0$, but $\Delta\neq0$ does not force spectral regularity. Hence the sector "reduced-norm-degenerate, spectrally regular" is empty, while its opposite is not: a vanishing reduced norm forces a whole half to vanish, and a vanishing half is scalar, hence spectrally degenerate. The biquaternion algebra differs: its norm is a sum, not a product, and its Hermitian idempotents are norm-degenerate with simple spectra.

Conventions. The split complex unit is $j$, with $j^2=1$, and the idempotents are $\tilde\Pi_{1,2}=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$. An element is $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ with $Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm$, $t_\pm\in\mathbb{R}$, $\vec q_\pm=\sum_k q_{\pm k}\vec e_k$, and $|\vec q_\pm|^2=\sum_k q_{\pm k}^2$. The quaternion norm is $|Q_\pm|^2=t_\pm^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$. The split-biquaternion norm is $\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}=|Q_+|^2\tilde\Pi_1+|Q_-|^2\tilde\Pi_2=\sum_\mu Q_\mu^2$, where $Q_\mu$ are the coefficients in the basis $e_\mu$. The reduced norm is $\Delta=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2=\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}^{*}$. The spectral classification is Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra; the sectors are The Three Sectors of the Split-Biquaternion Algebra; the algebra and norm are Split-Biquaternion Algebra and Split-Biquaternion Norm and Invertibility.

The Reduced Norm and the Component Invariants

Definitions and Identities

Lemma (the norm in the idempotent basis). For $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$,

$$ \langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}=|Q_+|^2\tilde\Pi_1+|Q_-|^2\tilde\Pi_2 =\sum_{\mu=t,x,y,z}Q_\mu^2. $$

Proof. Write $Q_\mu=a_\mu+jb_\mu$ with $a_\mu,b_\mu\in\mathbb{R}$. Since $a_\mu+jb_\mu=(a_\mu+b_\mu)\tilde\Pi_1+(a_\mu-b_\mu)\tilde\Pi_2$, the coefficient of $\tilde\Pi_1$ in $\sum_\mu Q_\mu^2$ is $\sum_\mu(a_\mu+b_\mu)^2$ and the coefficient of $\tilde\Pi_2$ is $\sum_\mu(a_\mu-b_\mu)^2$. Now $a_\mu=(q_{+\mu}+q_{-\mu})/2$ and $b_\mu=(q_{+\mu}-q_{-\mu})/2$, so

$$ \sum_\mu(a_\mu+b_\mu)^2=\sum_\mu q_{+\mu}^2=|Q_+|^2, \qquad \sum_\mu(a_\mu-b_\mu)^2=\sum_\mu q_{-\mu}^2=|Q_-|^2. $$

Definition (reduced norm). The reduced norm of $\tilde Q$ is

$$ \Delta(\tilde Q)=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2=\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}^{*}\in\mathbb{R}. $$

It is a homogeneous real quartic in the eight real coordinates.

Theorem (positivity and the zero criterion). For every $\tilde Q$,

$$ \Delta(\tilde Q)\ge0,\qquad \Delta(\tilde Q)=0\iff Q_+=0\text{ or }Q_-=0. $$

Consequently $\tilde Q$ is invertible exactly when $\Delta(\tilde Q)\neq0$.

Proof. Each $|Q_\pm|^2$ is a sum of four squares, hence non-negative and zero only at $Q_\pm=0$. A product of non-negative reals vanishes exactly when a factor vanishes. In $\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$, an element is invertible exactly when both components are non-zero, by Split-Biquaternion Norm and Invertibility.

Proposition (multiplicativity). The reduced norm is multiplicative:

$$ \Delta(\tilde Q_2\tilde Q)=\Delta(\tilde Q_2)\Delta(\tilde Q). $$

Proof. The halves multiply componentwise, $(\tilde Q_2\tilde Q)_\pm=P_\pm Q_\pm$. The quaternion norm is multiplicative, since $|PQ|^2=(PQ)(PQ)^{*}=PQQ^{*}P^{*}=|P|^2|Q|^2$. Hence

$$ \Delta(\tilde Q_2\tilde Q)=|P_+Q_+|^2|P_-Q_-|^2=|P_+|^2|P_-|^2|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2. $$

Definition (component invariants). The component invariants are $|\vec q_+|^2$ and $|\vec q_-|^2$. Each is a sum of three squares and is not multiplicative: $\vec e_x^2=-1$ has zero vector part while $|\vec e_x|^2|\vec e_x|^2=1$.

$\Delta$ is the product of the squared quaternion norms; the component invariants are the squared vector parts inside those norms. The identity $|Q_\pm|^2=t_\pm^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$ splits each factor of $\Delta$ into a scalar square and a vector square.

The Two Kinds of Invariant Side by Side

Invariant Formula Vanishes exactly when Multiplicative
$\Delta$ $\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\lvert Q_-\rvert^2$ $Q_+=0$ or $Q_-=0$ yes
$\lvert Q_+\rvert^2$ $t_+^2+\lvert\vec q_+\rvert^2$ $Q_+=0$ yes
$\lvert Q_-\rvert^2$ $t_-^2+\lvert\vec q_-\rvert^2$ $Q_-=0$ yes
$\lvert\vec q_+\rvert^2$ $q_{+x}^2+q_{+y}^2+q_{+z}^2$ $\vec q_+=0$ no
$\lvert\vec q_-\rvert^2$ $q_{-x}^2+q_{-y}^2+q_{-z}^2$ $\vec q_-=0$ no

A vanishing component invariant means only that one half is scalar; the half may still be a non-zero scalar, and then $\Delta$ is non-zero. A vanishing reduced norm is stronger: it requires a whole half to vanish.

Proposition (the only implications). The following hold.

(i) If $|\vec q_+|^2\neq0$ and $|\vec q_-|^2\neq0$, then $\Delta\neq0$. (ii) If $\Delta=0$, then $|\vec q_+|^2=0$ or $|\vec q_-|^2=0$. (iii) Neither converse holds.

Proof. (i) A non-zero vector part makes its half non-zero, so both factors of $\Delta$ are non-zero. (ii) By the zero criterion, one half is zero, so its vector part is zero. (iii) $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ has $|\vec q_+|^2=0$ but $\Delta=1$, so neither converse holds.

Independence in the Only Direction Available

Definition (the two predicates). An element is norm-regular when $\Delta\neq0$ and norm-degenerate when $\Delta=0$. It is spectrally regular when $p_{\tilde Q}$ has no repeated root and spectrally degenerate when it has one.

Theorem (the one-way implication). Spectral regularity implies norm regularity. Norm regularity does not imply spectral regularity.

Proof. If $\Delta=0$, then $Q_+=0$ or $Q_-=0$ by the zero criterion. If $Q_+=0$ then $\vec q_+=0$, so case 1 of the repeated-root theorem of Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra applies; the other case is the same. Hence spectral regularity forces $\Delta\neq0$.

For the converse, take $Q_+=1$ and $Q_-=\vec e_z$. Then $\Delta=1$ but $p_+=(\lambda-1)^2$ has a repeated root, so the element is spectrally degenerate.

Corollary (the mixed sectors). The sector $\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally degenerate}\}$ is non-empty, and the sector $\{\Delta=0,\ \text{spectrally regular}\}$ is empty.

The only independence available is the failure of the converse: An invertible element can have a repeated root, but a zero divisor cannot have a simple spectrum. In logical form,

$$ \text{spectrally regular}\Longrightarrow\text{norm-regular}, \qquad \text{norm-regular}\not\Longrightarrow\text{spectrally regular}. $$

There is no element that is norm-degenerate and spectrally regular.

The Empty Mixed Sector and Its Cause

Definition (the mixed sector). Let

$$ \Sigma_{01}=\{\tilde Q:\Delta(\tilde Q)=0\text{ and }p_{\tilde Q}\text{ has no repeated root}\}. $$

Theorem ($\Sigma_{01}$ is empty). No split biquaternion is both norm-degenerate and spectrally regular.

Proof. Let $\Delta(\tilde Q)=0$. By the zero criterion, $Q_+=0$ or $Q_-=0$. Suppose $Q_+=0$. Then $Q_+=0$ is the zero scalar, so $\vec q_+=0$; by the repeated-root theorem, $p_{\tilde Q}$ has a repeated root. The case $Q_-=0$ is identical. Hence spectral regularity fails.

The zero-divisor half is the zero scalar, so its reduced polynomial is $\lambda^2$, a double root at $0$. The other half may have a simple spectrum, but the double root already makes the element degenerate. A product of non-negative factors vanishes only through a zero factor.

Corollary (no norm-degenerate regular element). The empty sector is the failure of the converse. The non-empty sectors are $\Sigma_{11}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally regular}\}$, $\Sigma_{10}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally degenerate}\}$ and $\Sigma_{00}=\{\Delta=0\}$; their geometry is The Three Sectors of the Split-Biquaternion Algebra.

The Chain of Invariants

The zero criterion, the definition of a zero half, and the repeated-root criterion form a chain:

$$ \Delta=0 \iff Q_+=0\text{ or }Q_-=0 \implies \vec q_+=0\text{ or }\vec q_-=0 \implies p_{\tilde Q}\text{ has a repeated root}. $$

The first equivalence is the zero criterion; the second says a zero quaternion has zero scalar and vector parts; the third is case 1 or case 2. The chain is one-way: $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ has $\vec q_+=0$ and a repeated root but $\Delta=1$; $Q_+=\vec e_x$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ has both vector parts non-zero and a repeated root.

In terms of information, the invariants form a hierarchy:

Invariant Data What it determines
$\Delta$ one real number whether the element is invertible
$(\lvert Q_+\rvert^2,\lvert Q_-\rvert^2)$ two non-negative reals the two factors of $\Delta$ and which half vanishes
$(t_\pm,\lvert\vec q_\pm\rvert^2)$ four reals the two half-spectra and the repeated-root pattern
$p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$ a monic quartic the spectrum with the multiplicity of the reduced polynomial
$p_{\tilde Q}^2$ a monic octic the spectrum with the multiplicity of $L_{\tilde Q}$

The scalar/vector data determines the rest: the factor norms are $t_\pm^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$, $\Delta$ is their product, and $p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$. The reverse maps do not exist: $\Delta$ does not determine the factor norms, the factor norms do not determine the scalar/vector data, and $p_{\tilde Q}$ does not determine the pairing of roots with halves. The operator polynomial $p_{\tilde Q}^2$ adds only multiplicity.

Proposition (what $\Delta$ forgets). The reduced norm does not determine either component invariant, either scalar part, spectral regularity, or which half vanishes.

Proof. $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ has $\Delta=1$ and $|\vec q_+|^2=0$; $Q_+=\vec e_x$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ has $\Delta=1$ and $|\vec q_+|^2=1$. $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=2\vec e_z$ and $Q_+=2$, $Q_-=\vec e_z$ both have $\Delta=4$ and scalar parts $(1,2)$ and $(2,1)$. At the same value $\Delta=4$, $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=2\vec e_z$ is degenerate while $Q_+=\vec e_x$, $Q_-=2\vec e_z$ is regular. Finally, $Q_+=0$, $Q_-=1$ and $Q_+=1$, $Q_-=0$ both have $\Delta=0$ and different vanishing halves.

The comparison is thus of a product with its factors: $\Delta$ is the product, the component invariants are the internal vector squares, and the scalar parts are the remaining data.

Contrast with the Biquaternion Case

In the biquaternion algebra $\mathbb{B}=\mathbb{C}\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}\mathbb{H}$, the norm is

$$ \eta=Q_t^2+B^2,\qquad B^2=Q_x^2+Q_y^2+Q_z^2, $$

with $Q_\mu\in\mathbb{C}$. It is a sum, not a product. The norm-degenerate set is the complex cone $\{Q_t^2+B^2=0\}$, and the spectral-degenerate set is $\{B^2=0\}$. The mixed sector $\Sigma_{01}$ is non-empty; the witnesses are the Hermitian idempotents.

Let $\vec u\in\mathbb{R}^3$ with $\vec u\cdot\vec u=1$ and put

$$ E=\tfrac12(1+i\vec u). $$

The element $E$ is Hermitian, $E^*=E$. Then

$$ E^2=\tfrac14(1+2i\vec u+i^2\vec u^2) =\tfrac14(1+2i\vec u-\vec u^2) =\tfrac12(1+i\vec u)=E, $$

because $\vec u^2=-\vec u\cdot\vec u=-1$. Its scalar part is $1/2$ and its vector part is $i\vec u/2$, so

$$ \eta(E)=\tfrac14+\tfrac{i^2}{4}(\vec u\cdot\vec u)=\tfrac14-\tfrac14=0, \qquad B^2(E)=\tfrac{i^2}{4}(\vec u\cdot\vec u)=-\tfrac14\neq0. $$

Since $E^2=E$ and $E\neq0,1$, its minimal polynomial is $X(X-1)$, so the spectrum $\{0,1\}$ is simple. Thus $E$ is norm-degenerate and spectrally regular: it lies in the biquaternion $\Sigma_{01}$, the sector that is empty in the split algebra. These idempotents are non-central, form a two-sphere, and are rank-one projections in the matrix model $\mathbb{B}\cong M_2(\mathbb{C})$.

A sum can cancel: $Q_t^2$ and $B^2$ can be opposite non-zero complex numbers, whereas a product of non-negative reals needs a zero factor. And $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ has only the four central idempotents $0,\tilde\Pi_1,\tilde\Pi_2,1$, because each division algebra has only $0$ and $1$; a non-zero idempotent of the split algebra has a zero half. The biquaternion matrix algebra has non-central idempotents, and the Hermitian ones are the witnesses the split algebra cannot produce.

Summary

The reduced norm is $\Delta=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2$, the product of the two quaternion norms; it is real, non-negative, multiplicative, and vanishes exactly when one half vanishes. The component invariants vanish exactly when a half is scalar. A zero component invariant does not force $\Delta=0$ (the scalar half may be non-zero); $\Delta=0$ forces one component invariant to zero (the zero half).

Spectral regularity implies norm regularity but not conversely. $\Sigma_{01}$ is empty; $\Sigma_{10}$ is non-empty. The scalar/vector data determines the factor norms, their product $\Delta$, and $p_{\tilde Q}$; these maps do not reverse.

The biquaternion algebra has a sum, not a product. Its Hermitian idempotents $\tfrac12(1+i\vec u)$ have norm zero and spectrum $\{1,0\}$, so its $\Sigma_{01}$ is non-empty. The split algebra has no such element, and its empty sector measures the difference.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ Split-biquaternion algebra
$\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ Idempotent decomposition
$Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm$ A half
$\lvert Q_\pm\rvert^2=t_\pm^2+\lvert\vec q_\pm\rvert^2$ Quaternion norm of a half
$\lvert\vec q_\pm\rvert^2$ Component invariant, the squared vector part
$\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}=\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\tilde\Pi_1+\lvert Q_-\rvert^2\tilde\Pi_2$ Split-biquaternion norm
$\Delta=\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\lvert Q_-\rvert^2=\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}^{*}$ Reduced norm
$\Sigma_{01}=\{\Delta=0,\ \text{spectrally regular}\}$ The empty mixed sector
$\Sigma_{10}=\{\Delta\neq0,\ \text{spectrally degenerate}\}$ The non-empty mixed sector
$p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$ Reduced characteristic polynomial

Further Reading