Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra
Introduction
The split-biquaternion algebra $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}=\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}\mathbb{H}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ is a product of two copies of the quaternion division algebra. Its spectrum is therefore not a single quaternionic spectrum but the union of two of them: the spectrum of $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ is the union of the spectra of the halves $Q_+$ and $Q_-$. This article proves the formula and separates the two spectral cases: regular, with simple roots, and degenerate, with a repeated root.
The main results are these. The reduced characteristic polynomial is $p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$, with $p_\pm(\lambda)=(\lambda-t_\pm)^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$. A repeated root occurs exactly when one half is scalar or the half-spectra meet. Every element is semisimple, because each half lies in the division algebra $\mathbb{H}$; there is no defect. The contrast with the biquaternion algebra is sharp: there a complex isotropic vector exists and the spectral cone is defective off the scalar line; here the vector parts are real, their squared norms are sums of squares, and the product of two division algebras removes the defect.
Conventions. The split complex unit is $j$, with $j^2=1$, and it is central. The idempotents are $\tilde\Pi_{1,2}=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$. An element is written
$$ \tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2,\qquad Q_\pm\in\mathbb{H}, $$
with
$$ Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm,\qquad t_\pm\in\mathbb{R},\qquad \vec q_\pm=\sum_{k=x,y,z}q_{\pm k}\vec e_k,\qquad |\vec q_\pm|^2=\sum_{k=x,y,z}q_{\pm k}^2, $$
and quaternion norm $|Q_\pm|^2=t_\pm^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$. The split-biquaternion norm is
$$ \langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}=|Q_+|^2\tilde\Pi_1+|Q_-|^2\tilde\Pi_2 =\sum_{\mu=t,x,y,z}Q_\mu^2, $$
and the reduced norm is $\Delta=|Q_+|^2|Q_-|^2=\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}^{*}$. The algebra and idempotents are Split-Biquaternion Algebra and Split-Biquaternion Idempotents and Projections; the norm is Split-Biquaternion Norm and Invertibility; the spectrum is Split-Biquaternion Spectral Theory. The companion articles are The Reduced Norm and Spectral Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra and The Three Sectors of the Split-Biquaternion Algebra.
The Spectrum as the Union of the Two Half-Spectra
The Spectrum of a Quaternion Half
Definition (spectrum of a half). For $Q\in\mathbb{H}$, let $L_Q:\mathbb{H}\to\mathbb{H}$ be left multiplication, $L_Q(X)=QX$. The spectrum $\sigma(Q)$ is the set of complex eigenvalues of $L_Q$ after complexification.
Lemma (the spectrum of a quaternion). Write $Q=t+\vec q$ with $t\in\mathbb{R}$ and $\vec q\in\mathbb{R}^3$. If $\vec q\neq0$, then
$$ \sigma(Q)=\{t+i|\vec q|,\ t-i|\vec q|\}, $$
each value occurring with multiplicity two. If $\vec q=0$, then $\sigma(Q)=\{t\}$, with multiplicity four.
Proof. Suppose $\vec q\neq0$ and put $u=\vec q/|\vec q|$. Then $u^2=-1$ and $L_Q=t\,\mathrm{id}+|\vec q|L_u$. Right multiplication $R_u$ is a complex structure commuting with $L_u$, so $\mathbb{H}$ is a two-dimensional complex space and $L_u$ is complex-linear. Since $L_u^2=-\mathrm{id}$ and $\operatorname{tr}L_u=4\,\mathrm{Re}\,u=0$, its eigenvalues are $i$ and $-i$. Hence $L_Q$ has $t\pm i|\vec q|$, each with real multiplicity two. If $\vec q=0$, then $L_Q=t\,\mathrm{id}$ on $\mathbb{R}^4$.
The Spectrum of the Element
Definition (the spectrum). The spectrum of $\tilde Q$ is the spectrum of the real operator $L_{\tilde Q}$ on $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}$, complexified.
Theorem (the union formula). For $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$,
$$ \sigma(\tilde Q) =\{t_++i|\vec q_+|,\ t_+-i|\vec q_+|\} \cup \{t_-+i|\vec q_-|,\ t_--i|\vec q_-|\}. $$
Each value contributed by a half occurs twice in the characteristic polynomial of $L_{\tilde Q}$; when a half is scalar, its two values coincide and its contribution has multiplicity four.
Proof. The idempotents $\tilde\Pi_{1,2}$ are central, so for $X=X_+\tilde\Pi_1+X_-\tilde\Pi_2$ one has
$$ \tilde QX=(Q_+X_+)\tilde\Pi_1+(Q_-X_-)\tilde\Pi_2. $$
Hence $L_{\tilde Q}$ is the block diagonal operator $\mathrm{diag}(L_{Q_+},L_{Q_-})$ on the two copies of $\mathbb{H}$. The spectrum is the union of the two block spectra, with multiplicities added. The lemma gives the two displayed values and the multiplicities.
Corollary (the full characteristic polynomial). Let
$$ p_\pm(\lambda)=(\lambda-t_\pm)^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2. $$
The characteristic polynomial of $L_{\tilde Q}$ is
$$ \chi_{\tilde Q}(\lambda)=p_+(\lambda)^2p_-(\lambda)^2. $$
Proof. By the lemma, the characteristic polynomial of $L_{Q_\pm}$ is $p_\pm^2$: for a non-scalar half the two roots of $p_\pm$ each occur twice, and for a scalar half $p_\pm=(\lambda-t_\pm)^2$ and its square is $(\lambda-t_\pm)^4$. The block diagonal characteristic polynomial is the product.
The Reduced Characteristic Polynomial
Definition (reduced characteristic polynomial). The reduced characteristic polynomial is
$$ p_{\tilde Q}(\lambda)=p_+(\lambda)p_-(\lambda) =\bigl((\lambda-t_+)^2+|\vec q_+|^2\bigr)\bigl((\lambda-t_-)^2+|\vec q_-|^2\bigr). $$
It is the monic polynomial with $\chi_{\tilde Q}=p_{\tilde Q}^2$. Its roots are the spectrum values counted once per half.
Each half contributes its reduced polynomial $p_\pm$; the operator $L_{\tilde Q}$ doubles each factor, and $p_{\tilde Q}$ removes the doubling.
The Criterion for a Repeated Root
Theorem (repeated roots). The reduced polynomial $p_{\tilde Q}$ has a repeated root exactly when one of the following holds:
- $\vec q_+=0$;
- $\vec q_-=0$;
- $t_+=t_-$ and $|\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|$.
Proof. The polynomial $p_\pm$ has discriminant $-4|\vec q_\pm|^2$, so it has a double root exactly when $|\vec q_\pm|=0$, which is cases 1 and 2. A root is shared by $p_+$ and $p_-$ exactly when
$$ t_++\varepsilon i|\vec q_+|=t_-+\varepsilon' i|\vec q_-| $$
for some signs $\varepsilon,\varepsilon'\in\{1,-1\}$. If $\varepsilon=\varepsilon'$, comparison of real and imaginary parts gives $t_+=t_-$ and $|\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|$, which is case 3. If $\varepsilon=-\varepsilon'$, comparison of imaginary parts gives $|\vec q_+|=-|\vec q_-|$, hence both are zero, which is already contained in cases 1 and 2. Conversely, each of the three conditions produces a double root or a shared root.
Corollary (spectral regularity). The element is spectrally regular exactly when
$$ \vec q_+\neq0,\qquad \vec q_-\neq0,\qquad (t_+,|\vec q_+|)\neq(t_-,|\vec q_-|). $$
It is spectrally degenerate exactly when one of the three cases of the theorem holds.
The cases overlap at the origin and in the both-scalar part of case 3.
Semisimplicity and the Absence of Defect
Definition (semisimple and defective). An element of a finite-dimensional algebra is semisimple when its minimal polynomial is squarefree, equivalently when left multiplication by it is diagonalisable over the algebraic closure. An element is defective when it is not semisimple.
Lemma (division algebras have no defect). Every element of a finite-dimensional division algebra over $\mathbb{R}$ is semisimple.
Proof. Let $a$ be an element of a division algebra $D$ with minimal polynomial $m$. If $m=g^2h$ with $g$ non-constant, minimality gives $g(a)\neq0$ and $h(a)\neq0$, while $g(a)^2h(a)=0$; hence $g(a)$ is a zero divisor, impossible. Hence $m$ is squarefree.
Theorem (every split biquaternion is semisimple). Every element of $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ is semisimple. Consequently there is no defective element and no defective stratum.
Proof. The two halves $Q_\pm$ lie in $\mathbb{H}$, which is a division algebra, so each is semisimple by the lemma. In the direct sum $\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$, the minimal polynomial of $(Q_+,Q_-)$ is the least common multiple of the minimal polynomials of the two halves. A least common multiple of squarefree polynomials is squarefree, so $\tilde Q$ is semisimple.
Corollary (repetition is not defect). A repeated root of $p_{\tilde Q}$ does not make $\tilde Q$ defective. A scalar half has a linear minimal polynomial, not the repeated quadratic $p_\pm$; a shared value occurs in two different summands and is recorded once. In both cases the minimal polynomial remains squarefree.
The Contrast with the Biquaternion Complex Cone
In the biquaternion algebra $\mathbb{B}=\mathbb{C}\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}\mathbb{H}$, the vector part $\vec Q=Q_x\vec e_x+Q_y\vec e_y+Q_z\vec e_z$ has complex coefficients and
$$ B^2=Q_x^2+Q_y^2+Q_z^2,\qquad \vec Q^2=-B^2e_t. $$
When $B^2=0$ and $\vec Q\neq0$, the vector part is square-zero, so $L_{\vec Q}$ is nilpotent and $Q_te_t+\vec Q$ has minimal polynomial $(X-Q_t)^2$; it is defective. Thus the spectral cone $\{B^2=0\}$ has defect off its scalar line. This is The Spectrum, §The Two Cases and §The Degenerate Case: The Spectral-Degenerate Cone.
The split algebra cannot reproduce this phenomenon. Its vector parts have real coefficients, and
$$ |\vec q_\pm|^2=q_{\pm x}^2+q_{\pm y}^2+q_{\pm z}^2 $$
is a sum of squares, vanishing only at $\vec q_\pm=0$. There is no non-zero isotropic vector, hence no non-zero square-zero vector part, hence no defect of that kind. Structurally, $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ is a product of division algebras; a nilpotent in a product would have nilpotent components, and a division algebra has none.
The product structure explains why a meeting is harmless: in $\mathbb{B}$ the two eigenvalues live in the same simple algebra $M_2(\mathbb{C})$, so coalescence can force a Jordan block; in $\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ they live in different summands, so it is only an equality of values.
The Scalar Strata of the Halves
Definition (scalar strata). The scalar strata of the two halves are
$$ \mathcal S_+=\{\tilde Q:\vec q_+=0\},\qquad \mathcal S_-=\{\tilde Q:\vec q_-=0\}. $$
Proposition (geometry and size). Each scalar stratum is a real linear subspace of dimension five: one real parameter $t_\pm$ for the scalar half and four real parameters for the other half. Their intersection is the centre,
$$ \mathcal S_+\cap\mathcal S_-=\{(t_+,t_-):t_+,t_-\in\mathbb{R}\}=\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}, $$
of real dimension two.
Proof. The condition $\vec q_+=0$ removes three real coordinates, so $\dim\mathcal S_+=5$; likewise $\dim\mathcal S_-=5$. An element in both has both vector parts zero, so it is a pair of real scalars, exactly the centre $\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$.
Proposition (the spectrum on a scalar stratum). On $\mathcal S_+$ the plus half is the real scalar $t_+$, so $p_+=(\lambda-t_+)^2$ has a repeated root; hence $\mathcal S_+\cup\mathcal S_-$ is spectrally degenerate. If $t_+\neq0$ the half is a central unit; if $t_+=0$ it is the zero scalar.
Proof. This is case 1 of the repeated-root theorem. The unit and zero-divisor assertions are the invertibility criterion in the idempotent basis.
The scalar strata are the parts of the spectral-degenerate locus where the repetition happens inside one half. The remaining part is the meeting locus
$$ \mathcal M=\{\tilde Q:\vec q_+\neq0,\ \vec q_-\neq0,\ t_+=t_-,\ |\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|\}, $$
where two non-scalar halves share a spectrum value. The spectral-degenerate locus is the union
$$ \{\text{repeated root}\}=\mathcal S_+\cup\mathcal S_-\cup\mathcal M. $$
The scalar strata are linear; the meeting locus is not, being cut out by the equality of two norms.
Summary
The spectrum of a split biquaternion is the union of the spectra of its two quaternion halves. A half $Q=t+\vec q$ contributes $t\pm i|\vec q|$, each value twice; when the half is scalar the two values coincide and the multiplicity is four. The reduced characteristic polynomial is $p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$, with $p_\pm=(\lambda-t_\pm)^2+|\vec q_\pm|^2$, and the full characteristic polynomial of left multiplication is $p_{\tilde Q}^2$.
A repeated root occurs exactly when one half is scalar or when the two half-spectra meet. The three cases are $\vec q_+=0$, $\vec q_-=0$, and $t_+=t_-$ with $|\vec q_+|=|\vec q_-|$. Spectral regularity is the negation of this list.
Every element is semisimple, because each half lies in $\mathbb{H}$ and a direct sum of semisimple elements is semisimple. There is no defective element: a repeated root is a repetition of a value, not a Jordan block. The scalar strata are five-dimensional and meet in the two-dimensional centre; the biquaternion algebra, by contrast, has a complex vector part and defective elements off the scalar line. The product structure of the split algebra separates the two eigenvalue problems, and that is why the defect disappears.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $\mathbb{B}_{\mathrm{spl}}=\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}\otimes_{\mathbb{R}}\mathbb{H}\cong\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$ | Split-biquaternion algebra |
| $\tilde\Pi_{1,2}=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$ | Central idempotents |
| $\tilde Q=Q_+\tilde\Pi_1+Q_-\tilde\Pi_2$ | Idempotent decomposition into two quaternion halves |
| $Q_\pm=t_\pm+\vec q_\pm$ | A half, with real scalar part and real vector part |
| $\lvert Q_\pm\rvert^2=t_\pm^2+\lvert\vec q_\pm\rvert^2$ | Quaternion norm of a half |
| $\langle\tilde Q\rangle_{\natural}=\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\tilde\Pi_1+\lvert Q_-\rvert^2\tilde\Pi_2$ | Split-biquaternion norm |
| $\Delta=\lvert Q_+\rvert^2\lvert Q_-\rvert^2$ | Reduced norm |
| $p_\pm(\lambda)=(\lambda-t_\pm)^2+\lvert\vec q_\pm\rvert^2$ | Reduced characteristic polynomial of a half |
| $p_{\tilde Q}=p_+p_-$ | Reduced characteristic polynomial of the element |
| $\chi_{\tilde Q}=p_{\tilde Q}^2$ | Characteristic polynomial of $L_{\tilde Q}$ |
| $\sigma(\tilde Q)$ | Spectrum, the union of the two half-spectra |
| $\mathcal S_\pm=\{\vec q_\pm=0\}$ | Scalar strata of the halves |
| $\mathcal M$ | Meeting locus of the two non-scalar half-spectra |
Further Reading
- Split-Biquaternion Algebra, for the algebra, its idempotents and the isomorphism $\mathbb{H}\oplus\mathbb{H}$.
- Split-Biquaternion Idempotents and Projections, for the four idempotents.
- Split-Biquaternion Norm and Invertibility, for the norm, the reduced norm and the unit criterion.
- Split-Biquaternion Spectral Theory, for left multiplication and the quaternionic spectra.
- The Spectrum, for the complex cone and the defective elements off the scalar line.
- The Reduced Norm and Spectral Degeneracy in the Split-Biquaternion Algebra, for the comparison of the two predicates.
- The Three Sectors of the Split-Biquaternion Algebra, for the sectors and their dimensions.