The Spin-$\tfrac32$ Bispinors and the Minimal Left Ideals

Introduction

The subject. A bispinor of rank one is a spinor times a dual spinor, and the set of bispinors obtained by fixing the dual spinor is a minimal left ideal. The article proves the correspondence, computes its geometry, and reads the ideal as a fibre of the bispinor space.

The order of the article. The first section constructs the map from a spinor to a bispinor. The second proves that the fibres are the minimal left ideals. The third identifies the parameter space and its dimension. The fourth treats the two-sided and right versions. The fifth draws the boundary.

It assumes Introduction to the Spin-$\tfrac32$ Bispinor Spaces at $n=4$ and The Minimal Left Ideals of $M_4(\mathbb{C})$ and the Module $V_{3/2}$. The row at order two is The Spin-$\tfrac12$ Bispinors and the Minimal Left Ideals.

The result in one line. For a fixed nonzero dual spinor $\bar\chi$, the set $\{\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger}\}$ is a minimal left ideal of dimension four, and every minimal left ideal arises this way from a line of dual spinors.

Boundaries. The article treats the rank-one bispinors and the ideals they generate; the higher-rank bispinors are the subject of the rank articles.

From a Spinor to a Bispinor

Proposition. For fixed nonzero $\bar\chi$ the map $\psi\mapsto\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger}$ is injective and linear, with image the set of matrices whose rows are multiples of the row $\bar\chi^{\dagger}$.

Proof. The matrix $\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger}$ has entries $\psi_i\bar\chi_j$, so each row is $\bar\chi_j$ times the vector $\psi$; the map is injective because $\bar\chi\neq0$ gives a nonzero functional.

Corollary. The image has dimension four, and its nonzero elements have rank one.

Proof. The domain has dimension four; a nonzero product of a column and a row has rank one.

Corollary. The image is closed under left multiplication by any matrix and not under right multiplication.

Proof. $A(\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger})=(A\psi)\bar\chi^{\dagger}$ stays in the image; $(\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger})B=\psi(\bar\chi^{\dagger}B)$ changes the functional unless $B$ preserves the line.

The reading. The construction is the multiplication of the module by a fixed functional, and it produces a space of rank-one bispinors closed on the left.

The Fibres Are the Ideals

Proposition. The image of the map is the minimal left ideal $M_4P$ where $P$ is the rank-one idempotent projecting onto the line of the spinor $\psi_0$ paired with $\bar\chi$ to one.

Proof. The ideal $M_4P$ consists of the matrices whose rows lie in the row space of $P$, which is spanned by $\bar\chi^{\dagger}$; both spaces are four-dimensional and one contains the other.

Corollary. Every minimal left ideal arises from a line of dual spinors, and two dual spinors give the same ideal exactly when they are proportional.

Proof. The proposition and the injectivity of the correspondence between the line and the ideal.

Corollary. The minimal left ideals are the fibres of the projection of the bispinor space onto the second factor, restricted to the rank-one bispinors.

Proof. A rank-one bispinor determines its second factor up to a scalar.

The reading. The ideal is the fibre of the bispinor description: a spinor bundle whose base is the space of lines of dual spinors.

The Parameter Space

Proposition. The minimal left ideals are parametrised by the projective space $\mathbb{P}^{3}$ of lines of $\mathbb{C}^{4}$, of complex dimension three and real dimension six.

Proof. The lines of the dual space are the points of $\mathbb{P}^{3}$.

Corollary. The family of minimal left ideals has the same dimension as the family of rank-one idempotents of trace one, namely six real dimensions.

Proof. A rank-one idempotent is determined by its image line and its kernel hyperplane, which gives $3+3=6$ parameters.

Corollary. The union of the minimal left ideals is the set of matrices of rank at most one, the determinantal variety of the algebra.

Proof. Every rank-one matrix lies in the ideal determined by its row space.

The reading. The ideals form a family of dimension six inside the fifteen-dimensional projective space of the algebra.

The Right and Two-Sided Versions

Proposition. Fixing the first factor instead gives the minimal right ideals, parametrised by the lines of the spinor space, and the intersection of a minimal left ideal with a minimal right ideal is a line.

Proof. The right version is the transpose of the left; a left ideal has all rows in a fixed line, a right ideal has all columns in a fixed line, and their intersection is the rank-one matrix determined by the two lines. Note that the intersection is a line, so the two families meet transversally.

Corollary. A rank-one bispinor is the intersection of its left ideal and its right ideal, and it is determined by a spinor and a dual spinor up to a scalar.

Proof. The proposition and the parametrisation.

Corollary. The two-sided ideals are trivial: the algebra is simple, so its only two-sided ideals are zero and the whole algebra.

Proof. $M_4(\mathbb{C})$ is a simple algebra, having no nontrivial two-sided ideals.

The reading. The left and right families are dual to each other, and the rank-one bispinors are their transverse intersections.

The Boundary

Against the module article. That article constructs the ideal from an idempotent; this one constructs it from a dual spinor, and the two constructions agree.

Against the bispinor introduction. That article identifies the bispinor space with the algebra; this one restricts to the rank-one stratum and reads the ideals.

Against the rank article. The higher-rank bispinors do not generate minimal ideals, and their strata are treated separately.

A Final Observation

The bundle picture. The rank-one bispinors form a bundle over the product of two projective spaces, and the minimal left ideals are the fibres over the second factor; the rank is constant on each fibre, equal to one off the zero section.

The scale. The pair of spinors is determined up to a common scalar, so the projective class is the invariant object; the ideal records the second factor and the coideal the first, and the bispinor records both.

The Minimal Ideals in Coordinates

The columns. A minimal left ideal consists of the matrices whose columns lie in a fixed line, and the line is a point of the projective space of the module; the ideal is therefore the set of bispinors with a fixed right factor, up to scale.

The dimension. The ideal has complex dimension three, the sum of the one dimension of the fixed line and the two dimensions of the free left factor; it is the smallest nonzero left ideal, and every left ideal contains one.

The intersection. Two minimal left ideals meet in the zero matrix unless they share the line, in which case they coincide; the family of minimal left ideals is therefore a projective space of dimension three, and the algebra is the union of the ideals over that space.

The reading. The minimal left ideals are the fibres of the projection from the bispinor space onto the projective module, and each fibre is a copy of the module itself.

The Check of the Count

The number of ideals. The minimal left ideals are indexed by the points of the projective module, a projective space of dimension three, and over each point there is exactly one minimal left ideal; the total family is therefore a projective three-space of ideals.

Summary

For a fixed nonzero dual spinor the map $\psi\mapsto\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger}$ has a four-dimensional image, consisting of the matrices whose rows are multiples of the dual spinor, and that image is a minimal left ideal. Every minimal left ideal arises this way from a line of dual spinors, so the ideals are parametrised by $\mathbb{P}^{3}$.

The right ideals are obtained by fixing the first factor, and the intersection of a left ideal with a right ideal is a line spanned by a rank-one bispinor. The two-sided ideals are trivial.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$\psi\bar\chi^{\dagger}$ a rank-one bispinor
$M_4P$ the minimal left ideal it generates
$\mathbb{P}^{3}$ the parameter space of the ideals
$3+3=6$ the parameters of a rank-one idempotent

Further Reading