The Signed Adjoint Two-Sided Operator on a Lie Algebra
Introduction
The adjoint of an operator on a Lie algebra is taken with respect to the invariant Hermitian form of the category, and the adjoint of the signed two-sided operator is the operator that the form assigns to it. On a Lie algebra the two one-sided multiplications are anti-self-adjoint for an invariant form, so the adjoint of a product is the product of the adjoints in the reverse order, and the adjoint of the signed two-sided operator is a signed two-sided operator of the transposed type together with a correction by the commutator of the carrying pair. The form under which the signed two-sided operator agrees with its adjoint is the unitarity condition, and it is the condition under which the signed two-sided operator defines a unitary operator.
This article treats the adjoint of the signed two-sided operator on a Lie algebra, the explicit form of the adjoint and the unitarity condition it defines. It is the third article of the - * Operator Theory group of the category; the signed two-sided operator is The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Lie Algebra and its one-sided factors are The Signed Left Multiplication on a Lie Algebra, both above in the category, the invariant form and its adjoint are Hermitian Forms on a Lie Algebra, the star of the enveloping algebra is The Involution on the Enveloping Algebra of a Lie Group, and the adjoints of the remaining signed operators are The Signed Adjoint of the Reflection on a Lie Algebra, The Signed Adjoint of the Left Multiplication on a Lie Algebra and The Graded Adjoint Action on a Module over a Lie Algebra, below in this group.
The article assumes the Lie algebra and the bracket from Lie Groups, the invariant Hermitian form, its anti-self-adjoint adjoint operators and its positive definite case from Hermitian Forms on a Lie Algebra, the signed two-sided operator, its factorisation and its square from The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Lie Algebra, the signed left multiplication and its kernel from The Signed Left Multiplication on a Lie Algebra, and the grade involution and the grading from Graded Lie Algebras with an Involution. The form is used as an instrument and not as an object of study; the metric and the geometry of the form belong to Part IV.
The Adjoint Operation
The Adjoints of the Factors
Definition. Let $H$ be a non-degenerate invariant Hermitian form on $\mathrm{G}$, so that $H([x,y],z) + H(y,[x,z]) = 0$, and suppose that the grade involution is an isometry, $H(\alpha x,\alpha y) = H(x,y)$. The adjoint of an endomorphism $T$ is the endomorphism $T^{*}$ with
$$ H(Tx,y) = H(x,T^{*}y) \qquad (x,y\in\mathrm{G}) ; $$
the adjoint is conjugate-linear in the operator and reverses the order of a product, $(ST)^{*} = T^{*}S^{*}$.
Proposition. The one-sided multiplications and the grade involution have the adjoints
$$ L_a^{*} = -L_a, \qquad R_b^{*} = -R_b, \qquad \alpha^{*} = \alpha , $$
so all the multiplications are anti-self-adjoint and the grade involution is a self-adjoint isometry.
Proof. The invariance of $H$ is the identity $H([a,x],y) = -H(x,[a,y])$, which is $H(L_ax,y) = H(x,-L_ay) = H(x,L_{-a}y)$, hence $L_a^{*} = -L_a$; the right multiplication is the same with the antisymmetry, $R_b^{*} = -R_b$. The isometry condition is the hypothesis, and an isometry is an invertible operator with $\alpha^{*} = \alpha^{-1} = \alpha$.
Corollary. The adjoint of a two-sided operator is the composite of the adjoints in the reverse order,
$$ \Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \bigl(L_aR_b\alpha\bigr)^{*} = \alpha^{*}R_b^{*}L_a^{*} = \alpha R_bL_a , $$
and the adjoint of the unsigned two-sided operator is $\Sigma_{a,b}^{*} = R_bL_a$.
Proof. Substitute the three adjoints in the reversal formula; the signs $(-1)^2 = 1$ cancel.
The Explicit Form
Theorem (the explicit adjoint). For all $a,b\in\mathrm{G}$,
$$ \boxed{\;\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} - \alpha R_{[a,b]}\;} , $$
and since $\alpha R_{[a,b]} = R_{[\alpha(a),\alpha(b)]}\alpha$, the adjoint is a signed two-sided operator of the $\alpha$-transformed pair, corrected by the right multiplication of the commutator.
Proof. From $[L_a,R_b] = R_{[a,b]}$, proved from the Jacobi identity, one has $R_bL_a = L_aR_b - R_{[a,b]}$; multiplying by $\alpha$ on the left and using $\alpha L_a = L_{\alpha(a)}\alpha$, $\alpha R_b = R_{\alpha(b)}\alpha$ gives
$$ \alpha R_bL_a = \alpha L_aR_b - \alpha R_{[a,b]} = L_{\alpha(a)}R_{\alpha(b)}\alpha - R_{[\alpha(a),\alpha(b)]}\alpha = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} - \alpha R_{[a,b]} , $$
which is the formula.
Corollary (the commuting pair). If the carrying pair commutes, $[a,b] = 0$, then
$$ \Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} , $$
the last equality using that the pair is brought to itself by the grading when the elements are homogeneous; hence every signed two-sided operator with a commuting carrying pair is self-adjoint.
Proof. The correction vanishes when the commutator is zero; the equality with the original pair is the case distinction on the parities, the grading changing the sign of an odd parameter and the two-sided operator being even quadratically in each parameter.
The Unitarity Condition
Self-Adjointness
Theorem. The signed two-sided operator is self-adjoint if and only if the pair satisfies the commutation condition and the invariance condition
$$ \boxed{\;[a,b] = 0 \quad\text{and}\quad \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}\;} , $$
the second being automatic for homogeneous carrying elements; consequently the signed two-sided operator is self-adjoint for every pair of homogeneous commuting elements.
Proof. The adjoint is the formula above, so self-adjointness is the identity $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} - \alpha R_{[a,b]} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}$; separating the two-sided operator part from the right-multiplication part gives the two stated conditions, and the second holds for homogeneous parameters by the parity computation.
Anti-Self-Adjointness
Proposition. The signed two-sided operator is anti-self-adjoint if and only if
$$ 2\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = \alpha R_{[a,b]} , $$
an equation which on the odd part of the algebra becomes the vanishing of the second term; in particular no nonzero two-sided operator with an even commuting pair is anti-self-adjoint.
Proof. Anti-self-adjointness is $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = -\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}$; substitute the formula and rearrange.
Unitarity
Theorem (the unitarity condition). The signed two-sided operator is unitary for $H$ — that is, $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b}\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = \mathrm{id}$ — if and only if it is self-adjoint and its square is the identity,
$$ \boxed{\;\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b}\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = \mathrm{id} \iff [a,b] = 0 \ \text{and}\ \bigl(\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}\bigr)^{2} = \mathrm{id}\;} , $$
so that the unitary signed two-sided operators are exactly the involutive signed two-sided operators with a commuting carrying pair; the second condition is the centrality of the correction in the sense of the square of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Lie Algebra.
Proof. For a self-adjoint operator the unitary condition $\Sigma^{*}\Sigma = \mathrm{id}$ is $\Sigma^2 = \mathrm{id}$; conversely the unitary condition implies $\Sigma^{*} = \Sigma^{-1}$, which combined with the explicit form separates into the two stated conditions.
Corollary. The signed conjugation $\rho_a = \exp(\operatorname{ad}_a)\alpha$ is unitary for $H$ for every $a$, and it is self-adjoint exactly when it is an involution, that is when $a+\alpha(a)$ is central; the unitary reflections are the involutive ones.
Proof. The adjoint of the exponential is the exponential of the adjoint, $\rho_a^{*} = \alpha \exp(-\operatorname{ad}_a) = \rho_a^{-1}$, so the reflection is unitary; and it is self-adjoint exactly when $\rho_a = \rho_a^{-1}$, that is when its square is the identity. The condition for the involution is that of Reflections as Signed Two-Sided Operators on a Lie Algebra.
Relation to the Unsigned Case and the Form
The Adjoint of the Unsigned Two-Sided Operator
Proposition. The adjoint of the unsigned two-sided operator is $\Sigma_{a,b}^{*} = R_bL_a = \Sigma_{a,b} - R_{[a,b]}$; it is self-adjoint exactly when the carrying pair commutes, and it is the case $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$ of the general formula.
Proof. Substitute $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$ in the explicit form.
The Form Defined by the Operator
Theorem. The sesquilinear form
$$ H_{\Sigma}(x,y) = H\bigl(\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}x, y\bigr) - H\bigl(x,\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}y\bigr) $$
vanishes identically if and only if the signed two-sided operator is self-adjoint; the antisymmetric part of the two-sided operator with respect to $H$ is therefore the operator $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} - \alpha R_bL_a$, and the invariance of $H$ under the two-sided operator is exactly the self-adjointness.
Proof. The form is the defect of self-adjointness, and it vanishes exactly when $H(\Sigma x,y) = H(x,\Sigma y)$, which is the definition of the adjoint.
Corollary. The signed two-sided operator is a normal operator for $H$ exactly when it commutes with its adjoint; the defect $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b}\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} - \Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b}$ is the measure of the failure, and it vanishes for every commuting pair of homogeneous elements.
Proof. Normality is the vanishing of the commutator with the adjoint; for a commuting homogeneous pair the operator is self-adjoint by the corollary above, hence normal.
Examples
The Orthogonal Algebra
Let $\mathrm{G} = \mathrm{so}(3)$ with the negative definite form $H(X,Y) = -\frac12\operatorname{tr}(XY)$, which is positive definite and invariant; the algebra is compact, the left multiplications are anti-self-adjoint, and every signed two-sided operator with a commuting pair is self-adjoint. The Casimir operator is the negative of the Laplacian, and it is a positive self-adjoint combination of the two-sided operators.
The Rank-One Algebra
Let $\mathrm{G} = \mathrm{sl}_2(\mathbb{R})$ with the invariant form of signature $(2,1)$ given by the Killing form, and the Cartan involution as the grading. For an odd element $a$ and an even element $b$ with $[a,b] = 0$ the signed two-sided operator is self-adjoint; for a non-commuting pair the correction term is the right multiplication of the commutator, which is nonzero and destroys the self-adjointness.
A Degenerate Case
Let $\mathrm{G}$ be the Heisenberg algebra with the central element $Z$; the invariant scalar product is degenerate, vanishing on the radical spanned by $Z$, and there is no non-degenerate invariant form. The adjoint of a signed two-sided operator is then defined only on the quotient by the radical, and the unitarity condition fails on the radical; this is the degenerate case in which the form does not define an adjoint for every operator, treated further in Unitary Representations and the Orbit Method.
Summary
With respect to a non-degenerate invariant Hermitian form $H$ that the grade involution preserves, the one-sided multiplications are anti-self-adjoint, $L_a^{*} = -L_a$ and $R_b^{*} = -R_b$, and the grade involution is self-adjoint; hence the adjoint of the signed two-sided operator is the composite of the adjoints in the reverse order, $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \alpha R_bL_a$, with the explicit form
$$ \Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} - \alpha R_{[a,b]} , $$
a signed two-sided operator of the $\alpha$-transformed pair corrected by the right multiplication of the commutator. The signed two-sided operator is self-adjoint exactly when the carrying pair commutes and the two-sided operator is $\alpha$-invariant, which holds for homogeneous pairs; it is anti-self-adjoint only in the special case $2\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = \alpha R_{[a,b]}$, and it is unitary exactly when it is self-adjoint and its square is the identity, so the unitary signed two-sided operators are the involutive ones with a commuting carrying pair. The signed conjugation is unitary for every element, being the inverse of its adjoint, and it is self-adjoint exactly when it is an involution; the unsigned case is $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$, and the form defect $H(\Sigma x,y) - H(x,\Sigma y)$ measures the failure of the self-adjointness.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $H$ | a non-degenerate invariant Hermitian form |
| $T^{*}$ | the adjoint of $T$ for $H$ |
| $L_a^{*} = -L_a$, $R_b^{*} = -R_b$ | anti-self-adjointness of the multiplications |
| $\alpha^{*} = \alpha$ | the grade involution is a self-adjoint isometry |
| $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = L_aR_b\alpha$ | the signed two-sided operator |
| $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \alpha R_bL_a$ | the adjoint of the signed two-sided operator |
| $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b} = \Sigma^{\alpha}_{\alpha(a),\alpha(b)} - \alpha R_{[a,b]}$ | the explicit form |
| $[L_a,R_b] = R_{[a,b]}$ | the commutator identity used |
| $[a,b] = 0$ | the commuting carrying pair, self-adjointness |
| $\Sigma^{\alpha\,*}_{a,b}\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b} = \mathrm{id}$ | the unitarity condition |
| $\rho_a^{*} = \rho_a^{-1}$ | the reflection is unitary |
Further Reading
- Sigurdur Helgason, Differential Geometry, Lie Groups, and Symmetric Spaces (American Mathematical Society, 2001), for the invariant forms, the adjoint operators and the Casimir element.
- Anthony W. Knapp, Lie Groups Beyond an Introduction (Birkhäuser, second edition, 2002), for the invariant forms, the Cartan involution and the anti-self-adjoint operators.
- Max-Albert Knus, Alexander Merkurjev, Markus Rost and Jean-Pierre Tignol, The Book of Involutions (American Mathematical Society, 1998), for the adjoint of a signed operator and the unitarity conditions.
- Gerald B. Folland, A Course in Abstract Harmonic Analysis (CRC Press, second edition, 2015), for the unitary conditions and the adjoints of the multiplication operators.
- V. S. Varadarajan, Lie Groups, Lie Algebras, and Their Representations (Springer, 1984), for the invariant forms, the adjoints and the unitary representations.