Star-Derivations and the Anti-Hermitian Derivations
Introduction
A derivation of a ring is an additive map satisfying the Leibniz rule, and on a ring with an involution it is natural to ask how the derivation interacts with the involution. Two classes arise: the star-derivations, also called $\sigma$-derivations or -derivations, which commute with the involution, and the anti-Hermitian derivations*, which anticommute with it. Every derivation splits into a star part and an anti-Hermitian part when $2$ is invertible, the star-derivations preserve the symmetric and the anti-Hermitian elements while the anti-Hermitian derivations exchange them, and the inner derivations $D_a(x) = ax-xa$ realise the Lie structure: $D_a$ is a star-derivation exactly when $a+\sigma(a)$ is central and an anti-Hermitian derivation exactly when $a-\sigma(a)$ is central, so the inner derivations see the symmetric and anti-Hermitian elements through the commutator.
This article defines the two classes, proves the decomposition, computes the action on the symmetric and the anti-Hermitian elements, and derives the Lie structure of the inner derivations and its restriction to the anti-Hermitian elements. It assumes Derivations of a Ring for the Leibniz rule and the inner derivations, Involutive Rings for the involution and The Skew Field of a Ring with Involution for the symmetric and anti-Hermitian elements; the Lie algebra of the derivations is named from the later category and used only through the identity $[D_a,D_b] = D_{[a,b]}$. Throughout, $A$ is a ring with $1 \neq 0$ and an involution $\sigma$, $2$ is invertible when the decompositions are used, $\operatorname{Der}(A)$ is the Lie algebra of the derivations with $[D,E] = DE-ED$, and $\mathrm{sym}$, $\mathrm{Skew}$ are the symmetric and anti-Hermitian elements.
The Two Classes
Definition. A $\sigma$-derivation is an additive map $\delta : A\to A$ with
$$ \boxed{\;\delta(ab) = \delta(a)\,b + \sigma(a)\,\delta(b) \qquad \text{for all } a, b \in A\;} ; $$
when $\sigma = \mathrm{id}$ this is a derivation. A derivation $D$ is a star-derivation when
$$ D(\sigma(a)) = \sigma(D(a)) \quad \text{for all } a, \qquad \text{that is } D\sigma = \sigma D, $$
and a anti-Hermitian derivation when
$$ D(\sigma(a)) = -\sigma(D(a)) \quad \text{for all } a, \qquad \text{that is } D\sigma = -\sigma D . $$
Proposition (the decomposition). A derivation $D$ is a star-derivation exactly when $\sigma D\sigma = D$, and an anti-Hermitian derivation exactly when $\sigma D\sigma = -D$, where $\sigma D\sigma$ is the conjugate derivation $a \mapsto \sigma(D(\sigma(a)))$. Every derivation decomposes uniquely as
$$ \boxed{\;D = D_+ + D_-, \qquad D_+ = \tfrac12(D+\sigma D\sigma), \quad D_- = \tfrac12(D-\sigma D\sigma)\;}, $$
with $D_+$ a star-derivation and $D_-$ an anti-Hermitian derivation.
Proof. $\sigma D\sigma$ is additive and satisfies the Leibniz rule because $\sigma$ is an anti-automorphism: $\sigma D\sigma(ab) = \sigma D(\sigma(b)\sigma(a)) = \sigma(D\sigma(b)\sigma(a)+\sigma(b)D\sigma(a)) = \sigma(D\sigma(b))\,\sigma(\sigma(a))+\sigma(\sigma(b))\,\sigma(D\sigma(a)) = \sigma D\sigma(b)\,a + b\,\sigma D\sigma(a)$. A derivation $D$ commutes with $\sigma$ exactly when $\sigma D\sigma = D$ and anticommutes exactly when $\sigma D\sigma = -D$; the two projections are computations with $\sigma D\sigma$ and $\sigma^2 = \mathrm{id}$, and uniqueness is the invertibility of $2$.
Proposition (action on the eigenspaces). A star-derivation preserves $\mathrm{sym}$ and $\mathrm{Skew}$; an anti-Hermitian derivation exchanges them, $D(\mathrm{sym})\subseteq\mathrm{Skew}$ and $D(\mathrm{Skew})\subseteq\mathrm{sym}$.
Proof. For a star-derivation and $a \in \mathrm{sym}$, $\sigma(D(a)) = D(\sigma(a)) = D(a)$; for $a\in\mathrm{Skew}$, $\sigma(D(a)) = D(-a) = -D(a)$. For an anti-Hermitian derivation and $a\in\mathrm{sym}$, $\sigma(D(a)) = -D(\sigma(a)) = -D(a)$; and for $a\in\mathrm{Skew}$, $\sigma(D(a)) = -D(-a) = D(a)$.
The Inner Derivations
Theorem. For $a \in A$ let $D_a$ be the inner derivation $D_a(x) = ax-xa$. Then $D_a$ is a star-derivation exactly when $a+\sigma(a)$ is central, and an anti-Hermitian derivation exactly when $a-\sigma(a)$ is central:
$$ \boxed{\;D_a\sigma = \sigma D_a \iff a+\sigma(a)\in Z(A), \qquad D_a\sigma = -\sigma D_a \iff a-\sigma(a)\in Z(A)\;}. $$
In particular a central element gives the zero derivation, a symmetric element gives a antisymmetric derivation, and a antisymmetric element gives a star-derivation; for a central element both conditions hold and $D_a = 0$.
Proof. $\sigma(D_a x) = \sigma(ax-xa) = \sigma(x)\sigma(a)-\sigma(a)\sigma(x)$ and $D_a(\sigma(x)) = a\sigma(x)-\sigma(x)a$. The two agree for all $x$ exactly when $\sigma(x)\sigma(a)+a \sigma(x) = \sigma(a)\sigma(x)+\sigma(x)a$ for all $x$ — the transposition of the equality $\sigma(x)(\sigma(a)+a) = (a+\sigma(a))\sigma(x)$ for all $x$ — which is the centrality of $a+\sigma(a)$. The anti-Hermitian case is the same computation with the sign.
Theorem (the Lie structure). The inner derivations form a Lie subalgebra of $\operatorname{Der}(A)$ with $[D_a,D_b] = D_{ab-ba}$, and the assignment $a \mapsto D_a$ is a Lie algebra homomorphism $A \to \operatorname{Der}(A)$ with kernel the centre $Z(A)$, where $A$ is read with the commutator bracket. Under it the symmetric elements map to the anti-Hermitian derivations and the anti-Hermitian elements to the star-derivations, so $\mathrm{sym}(A,\sigma)/(\mathrm{sym}\cap Z)$ embeds as a Lie subalgebra of the anti-Hermitian derivations and $\mathrm{Skew}(A,\sigma)/(\mathrm{Skew}\cap Z)$ as a Lie subalgebra of the star-derivations.
Proof. $[D_a,D_b](x) = D_a(D_bx)-D_b(D_ax) = D_{ab-ba}(x)$ by the direct computation $a(bx-xb)-(bx-xb)a-b(ax-xa)+(ax-xa)b = (ab-ba)x-x(ab-ba)$. The kernel of $a\mapsto D_a$ is the centre, because $D_a = 0$ means $a$ commutes with every element. The image classes are those of the previous theorem: a symmetric element $a$ has $a-\sigma(a) = 0$ and so gives an anti-Hermitian derivation, an anti-Hermitian element gives a star-derivation, and in the quotients by the central elements the conditions are the stated ones; the homomorphism property carries the commutator to the commutator, so the images of the two Lie subalgebras are Lie subalgebras of the corresponding classes.
Corollary (the graded Lie structure). Under the parity star $= $ even, anti-Hermitian $=$ odd, the commutator satisfies $[\mathrm{star},\mathrm{star}]\subseteq\mathrm{star}$, $[\mathrm{star},\mathrm{anti}]\subseteq\mathrm{anti}$ and $[\mathrm{anti},\mathrm{anti}]\subseteq\mathrm{star}$; the star-derivations form a Lie subalgebra of $\operatorname{Der}(A)$, the anti-Hermitian derivations a module over it, and the commutator of two anti-Hermitian derivations is a star-derivation.
Proof. For star $D, E$ one has $[\sigma D\sigma,\sigma E\sigma] = [D,E]$; for star $D$ and anti-Hermitian $E$, $[\sigma D\sigma,\sigma E\sigma] = [D,-E] = -[D,E]$; for anti-Hermitian $D,E$, $[\sigma D\sigma,\sigma E\sigma] = [-D,-E] = [D,E]$. These are the three cases, and the closure of the star-derivations is the first.
Examples
(a) The matrix transpose. $A = M_n(R)$ with the transpose; the inner derivation $D_X$ is a star-derivation exactly when $X+X^{\mathrm t}$ is a scalar matrix and an anti-Hermitian derivation exactly when $X-X^{\mathrm t}$ is scalar. The symmetric matrices therefore give anti-Hermitian derivations and the antisymmetric matrices give star-derivations, and the derivations of the matrix ring are all inner by the matrix case of Derivations of a Ring.
(b) The quaternion conjugation. For the quaternion algebra with $D_x(y)=xy-yx$, a pure quaternion is an anti-Hermitian element and so gives a star-derivation, while a real scalar is symmetric and gives the zero or an anti-Hermitian derivation according as it is central; the embedding of the pure quaternions in the star-derivations is the three-dimensional Lie algebra of The Skew Field of a Ring with Involution read through the adjoint representation $a\mapsto D_a$.
(c) The differential operator. On $A = k[x]$ with the involution $\sigma(x) = -x$ and $\sigma|_k = \mathrm{id}$, the derivation $d/dx$ satisfies $D\sigma = -D$, that is it anticommutes with the involution, so it is an anti-Hermitian derivation; it exchanges the even and the odd polynomials, $\mathrm{sym} = k[x^2]$ and $\mathrm{Skew} = xk[x^2]$, exactly as in the proposition.
(d) The zero case. Every central element gives the zero inner derivation; the star-derivations and the anti-Hermitian derivations therefore contain the zero derivation, and the decomposition $D = D_++D_-$ is the one of a derivation into its $\sigma$-commuting and $\sigma$-anticommuting parts, the analogue for derivations of the eigenspace decomposition of an element.
Summary
A $\sigma$-derivation satisfies $\delta(ab) = \delta(a)b+\sigma(a)\delta(b)$ and is a derivation when $\sigma = \mathrm{id}$; a derivation is a star-derivation when $D\sigma = \sigma D$ and a anti-Hermitian derivation when $D\sigma = -\sigma D$, and every derivation decomposes as $D = D_++D_-$ with $D_\pm = \tfrac12(D\pm\sigma D\sigma)$ when $2$ is invertible. Star-derivations preserve the symmetric and the anti-Hermitian elements, anti-Hermitian derivations exchange them, and for the inner derivation $D_a$, $D_a$ is a star-derivation exactly when $a+\sigma(a)$ is central and an anti-Hermitian derivation exactly when $a-\sigma(a)$ is central. The inner derivations obey $[D_a,D_b] = D_{ab-ba}$, so $a\mapsto D_a$ is a Lie homomorphism with kernel the centre, the anti-Hermitian elements embedding as a Lie subalgebra of the anti-Hermitian derivations and the symmetric elements as one of the star-derivations; the star-derivations are closed under the commutator, the anti-Hermitian derivations are a module over them, and the commutator of two anti-Hermitian derivations is a star-derivation, the graded Lie structure of the two classes.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $\delta(ab)=\delta(a)b+\sigma(a)\delta(b)$ | $\sigma$-derivation; derivation when $\sigma=\mathrm{id}$ |
| $D\sigma=\sigma D$ | Star-derivation |
| $D\sigma=-\sigma D$ | Anti-Hermitian derivation |
| $D_\pm=\tfrac12(D\pm\sigma D\sigma)$ | Star and anti-Hermitian parts, $2$ invertible |
| $D(\mathrm{sym})\subseteq\mathrm{sym}$, $D(\mathrm{Skew})\subseteq\mathrm{Skew}$ | Star-derivation preserves the eigenspaces |
| $D(\mathrm{sym})\subseteq\mathrm{Skew}$, $D(\mathrm{Skew})\subseteq\mathrm{sym}$ | Anti-Hermitian derivation exchanges them |
| $D_a(x)=ax-xa$ | Inner derivation |
| $a+\sigma(a)\in Z$ / $a-\sigma(a)\in Z$ | $D_a$ star / anti-Hermitian |
| $[D_a,D_b]=D_{ab-ba}$ | Lie homomorphism $a\mapsto D_a$, kernel $Z(A)$ |
| $[\mathrm{star},\mathrm{anti}]\subseteq\mathrm{anti}$ | Graded Lie structure of the two classes |
Further Reading
- I. N. Herstein, Rings with Involution (University of Chicago Press, 1976), for the star-derivations, the anti-Hermitian derivations and the inner derivations of a ring with involution.
- Nathan Jacobson, Structure of Rings, American Mathematical Society Colloquium Publications 37 (1964), for the derivation algebra, the inner derivations and the Lie structure of a simple ring.
- Matej Brešar, Introduction to Noncommutative Algebra (Springer, 2014), for the $\sigma$-derivations, the Lie structure of the derivations and the functional identities they satisfy.
- Max-Albert Knus, Alexander Merkurjev, Markus Rost and Jean-Pierre Tignol, The Book of Involutions, American Mathematical Society Colloquium Publications 44 (1998), for the relation between the derivations and the involutions of a central simple algebra.