Relations between the Split Norm and Spectral Regularity and Degeneracy

Introduction

An element $q=t+bj$ carries two quadratic conditions. The split norm $q\bar q=t^2-b^2$ is the determinant of left multiplication and the product of the eigenvalues; it vanishes exactly on the non-invertibles. The spectral condition $b^2$ is a quarter of the discriminant and the square of half the eigenvalue difference; it vanishes exactly when the eigenvalues coincide. This article compares them, proves that neither implies the other, and reads the four combinations as four sectors. The mixed sectors are the point: a zero divisor with distinct eigenvalues, and an invertible element with a repeated one.

Notation. An element is $q=t+bj$, its conjugate is $\bar q=t-bj$, and the idempotents are $e_\pm=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$. The idempotent coordinates are $u=t+b$ and $v=t-b$, so that $q=ue_+ +ve_-$, the eigenvalues are $\lambda_+=u$ and $\lambda_-=v$, the split norm is $q\bar q=uv$, and $b=(u-v)/2$. The split norm is indefinite and is not a length. The corpus writes the same element $Q=q+jq'$, with its $q,q'$ equal to $t,b$ here and its $\Pi_\pm$ equal to the $e_\pm$.

The Two Conditions in One Quadratic

Definition (the two conditions). The split norm of $q$ is $q\bar q=t^2-b^2$; the element is norm-regular when the norm is non-zero and norm-degenerate when it is zero. The spectral condition is $b^2$; the element is spectrally regular when $b\neq0$ and spectrally degenerate when $b=0$.

Theorem (one polynomial carries both). For every $q$,

$$ p_q(X)=X^2-2tX+q\bar q=(X-\lambda_+)(X-\lambda_-), \qquad \lambda_\pm=t\pm b. $$

The split norm is the constant term and the product of the eigenvalues; the spectral condition is a quarter of the discriminant and the square of half their difference:

$$ q\bar q=\lambda_+\lambda_-,\qquad b^2=\frac{(\lambda_+-\lambda_-)^2}{4},\qquad \operatorname{disc}p_q=4b^2. $$

Proof. The characteristic polynomial of $L_q$ is $X^2-2tX+t^2-b^2$, and its roots are $t\pm b$. The product and the difference of the roots give the displayed identities.

Corollary. The split norm vanishes exactly when one eigenvalue is zero; the spectral condition vanishes exactly when the eigenvalues coincide.

Proof. The product is $q\bar q$, and the difference is $\lambda_+-\lambda_-=2b$.

Proposition (multiplicativity). For $q_1,q_2\in\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$, $(q_1q_2)\overline{(q_1q_2)}=(q_1\bar q_1)(q_2\bar q_2)$.

Proof. The conjugation is an automorphism and the algebra is commutative: $(q_1q_2)\overline{(q_1q_2)}=q_1q_2\bar q_2\bar q_1=q_1\bar q_1q_2\bar q_2$.

Proposition (the spectral condition is not multiplicative). The elements $q_1=2+j$ and $q_2=-2+j$ have $b^2=1$, and $q_1q_2=-3$ has $b^2=0$.

Proof. Direct computation: $(2+j)(-2+j)=-4+2j-2j+1=-3$.

Corollary (the invertibility criterion). For $q\neq0$, $q$ is invertible exactly when $q\bar q\neq0$; then $q^{-1}=\bar q/(q\bar q)$. If the norm vanishes, $q$ is a zero divisor.

Proof. The product $q\bar q$ is real and equals $\bar q q$, so the formula gives an inverse when the denominator is non-zero. When it vanishes and $q\neq0$, the element is a non-invertible in a finite-dimensional algebra, hence a zero divisor.

Independence of the Two Conditions

Theorem (independence). The two conditions are independent: neither implication $q\bar q=0\Rightarrow b=0$ and $b=0\Rightarrow q\bar q=0$ holds, and all four combinations occur.

Proof. Two witnesses.

  • $q_1=1+j$ has $q_1\bar q_1=0$ and $b=1$; its spectrum is $\{2,0\}$.
  • $q_2=2$ has $q_2\bar q_2=4$ and $b=0$; its spectrum is $\{2\}$.

The first is norm-degenerate and spectrally regular; the second is norm-regular and spectrally degenerate. The other combinations occur at $2+j$, with norm $3$ and $b=1$, and at $0$.

Corollary (the zero loci meet only at the origin). If $q\bar q=0$ and $b=0$, then $t=0$ and $q=0$.

Proof. The second condition gives $b=0$; the first then gives $t^2=0$.

Corollary (four non-empty sectors). The four sets

$$ \Sigma_{11}=\{q\bar q\neq0,\ b\neq0\},\quad \Sigma_{01}=\{q\bar q=0,\ b\neq0\},\quad \Sigma_{10}=\{q\bar q\neq0,\ b=0\},\quad \Sigma_{00}=\{q\bar q=0,\ b=0\} $$

are all non-empty, and $\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ is their disjoint union.

Proof. The witnesses lie in the first three, and $0$ lies in the fourth. Each element has one truth value for each condition, so it lies in one combination. The first index is the split norm, $1$ for non-vanishing and $0$ for vanishing; the second is the spectral condition, with the same convention.

The Null Lines

The null lines are $t=\pm b$; away from the origin their elements are zero divisors with distinct eigenvalues.

Theorem (the null lines). For $q\neq0$, the following are equivalent:

  1. $q\bar q=0$;
  2. $b=\pm t$;
  3. $q=2t e_+$ or $q=2t e_-$ with $t\neq0$;
  4. $\sigma(q)=\{2t,0\}$;
  5. $q$ is a zero divisor;
  6. $q$ is spectrally regular.

Each admits the two-term spectral decomposition $q=2t\,e_\pm +0\cdot e_\mp$.

Proof. (1)$\iff$(2): $t^2-b^2=(t-b)(t+b)$, and $q\neq0$ excludes $t=b=0$. (2)$\iff$(3): if $b=t$, then $q=t(1+j)=2t e_+$; if $b=-t$, then $q=t(1-j)=2t e_-$. (3)$\iff$(4): $e_\pm$ are eigenvectors with eigenvalues $2t$ and $0$, distinct because $t\neq0$. (4)$\iff$(6): the spectrum has two elements exactly when $b\neq0$. (3)$\iff$(5): if $q=2t e_+$ then $qe_-=0$ with $e_-\neq0$, and symmetrically; conversely a zero divisor is a non-invertible, so $q\bar q=0$ by the unit criterion.

Corollary (the annihilators). On the null cone,

$$ \operatorname{ann}(2t e_+)=\mathbb{R}e_-,\qquad \operatorname{ann}(2t e_-)=\mathbb{R}e_+,\qquad t\neq0. $$

Proof. For $q=2t e_+$ and $w=w_+e_++w_-e_-$, the product is $2t w_+e_+$, which vanishes exactly when $w_+=0$.

Corollary (the zero-divisor set). The zero-divisor set is exactly $\Sigma_{01}$, the two null lines with the origin removed. It has real dimension one and four connected components, the rays determined by the sign of $t$; its closure is $\mathcal{N}=\{q\bar q=0\}$.

Proof. The theorem identifies the zero divisors with the non-zero null elements. Each punctured line has the rays $t>0$ and $t<0$.

The Real Axis Minus the Origin

The real axis minus the origin is the sector of invertibles with a repeated eigenvalue: the norm is positive and the spectrum is a singleton.

Theorem (the real axis). For $q=t$ with $t\neq0$, one has $q\bar q=t^2>0$, $q^{-1}=1/t$, $\sigma(q)=\{t\}$, and minimal polynomial $X-t$. The element is norm-regular and spectrally degenerate, with the one-term spectral decomposition $q=t\cdot1$.

Proof. The norm is $t^2$, and $1/t$ is the inverse. The characteristic polynomial is $(X-t)^2$, whose only root is $t$; the minimal polynomial is $X-t$ because $q-t=0$.

Corollary. The sector $\Sigma_{10}$ is exactly $\mathbb{R}^{\times}$, with the two components $\mathbb{R}_{>0}$ and $\mathbb{R}_{<0}$.

Proof. The conditions are $b=0$ and $t^2-b^2=t^2\neq0$, that is $t\neq0$.

The sign of the norm does not isolate this sector: $\Sigma_{11}$ also contains elements with positive norm. What isolates it is $b=0$.

The Origin

The origin is the unique element degenerate for both conditions, and the two degenerations coincide there.

Theorem (the doubly degenerate element). The element $q=0$ is the only one with $q\bar q=0$ and $b=0$. Its spectrum is $\{0\}$, its minimal polynomial is $X$, and it is not a zero divisor.

Proof. The conditions give $t^2=b^2$ and $b=0$, hence $t=0$. The spectrum of $0$ is $\{0\}$ and its minimal polynomial is $X$. The definition of a zero divisor excludes $0$.

The origin is $\mathcal{N}\cap\mathcal{S}$, the intersection of the null cone and the spectral-degenerate line. It is doubly degenerate but not a zero divisor.

The Chain of Invariants

The norm is the constant term of the characteristic polynomial, and the chain stops at the characteristic polynomial.

invariant data degeneration types
split norm $q\bar q=t^2-b^2$ $2$: zero and non-zero
spectral condition $b^2$ $2$: zero and non-zero
characteristic polynomial $(2t,q\bar q)$ $4$: the root patterns
minimal polynomial $m_q$ $4$: no new stratum

Theorem (the chain). The split norm is the constant term of $p_q$. The characteristic polynomial determines $t$ and $b^2=t^2-q\bar q$, hence the sector and the unordered pair of eigenvalues. The minimal polynomial determines the characteristic polynomial by

$$ p_q= \begin{cases} m_q, & \deg m_q=2,\\ m_q^2, & \deg m_q=1. \end{cases} $$

Consequently the minimal polynomial separates exactly the four sectors and adds no stratum.

Proof. The coefficients $2t$ and $q\bar q$ give $t$ and $b^2=t^2-q\bar q$; the eigenvalues $t\pm b$ follow up to order. If $b\neq0$, the minimal polynomial is $p_q$; if $b=0$, it is $X-t$ and its square is $p_q$. The four root patterns are two distinct non-zero roots, two distinct roots with one zero, a double non-zero root, and a double root at zero; they are the four sectors.

In the biquaternion algebra, as The Spectrum proves, the minimal polynomial refines the degenerate cone into a scalar, a nilpotent and a unipotent stratum, and the last two are defective. In $\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ no refinement exists, because the algebra is reduced and every element is semisimple.

The Place of the Case Among the Algebras of the Corpus

The plane is the only algebra of the table in which the conditions are independent and neither creates a defect.

algebra norm spectral-degenerate locus defective elements $\Sigma_{01}$ non-empty
$\mathbb{C}$ $t^2+b^2$, positive definite real axis none no
$\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ $t^2-b^2$, indefinite real axis none yes
$\mathbb{H}$ $t^2+\lVert\vec v\rVert^2$, positive definite real axis none no
$\mathbb{H}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ indefinite the cone $\langle\vec v\rangle_{\natural}=0$ non-zero null vector part yes
$\mathbb{B}$ $Q_t^2+B^2$, complex-valued the cone $B^2=0$ nilpotent and unipotent strata yes

In $\mathbb{C}$ and $\mathbb{H}$ the norm is positive definite and vanishes only at the origin; $\Sigma_{01}$ is empty and the picture has three non-empty sectors, with $\Sigma_{00}=\{0\}$. In $\mathbb{H}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ and $\mathbb{B}$ the mixed sectors are non-empty, but the degenerate locus is a cone carrying defective elements. In $\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$ the norm is indefinite, the conditions are independent, the degenerate locus is a line, and every element is semisimple. The plane is therefore the unique algebra with four non-empty sectors and no defective stratum; the geometry of the sectors is The Four Sectors of the Split-Complex Algebra.

The sign of $j^2$ separates the definite norm and complex spectrum of $\mathbb{C}$ from the indefinite norm and real spectrum of $\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}$.

Summary

The split norm $q\bar q=t^2-b^2$ is the determinant of $L_q$ and the product of the eigenvalues; it decides invertibility. The spectral condition $b^2$ is a quarter of the discriminant; it decides whether the spectrum is separated. Both sit in $p_q(X)=X^2-2tX+q\bar q$: the norm as constant term, $4b^2$ as discriminant.

The conditions are independent: $1+j$ has zero norm and eigenvalues $2,0$; $2$ has non-zero norm and repeated eigenvalue $2$. The null lines $t=\pm b$ are the zero divisors; the real axis minus the origin is the group of invertibles with repeated eigenvalue $t$; the origin is the unique element degenerate for both and is not a zero divisor.

The four combinations are $\Sigma_{11}$, $\Sigma_{01}$, $\Sigma_{10}$ and $\Sigma_{00}$. The norm separates units from non-invertibles, the spectral condition regular from degenerate spectra, and the characteristic polynomial the four sectors. The minimal polynomial adds nothing: it reproduces the same four types, unlike the biquaternion case, where it refines the degenerate cone into three strata. The plane is the unique algebra of the table with four non-empty sectors and no defective element.

Summary of Notation

symbol meaning
$\mathbb{C}_{\mathrm{spl}}=\mathbb{R}[j]/(j^2-1)$ the split-complex algebra
$q=t+bj$ a general element, $t,b\in\mathbb{R}$
$\bar q=t-bj$ the conjugation
$q\bar q=t^2-b^2$ the split norm
$u=t+b,\ v=t-b$ the idempotent coordinates and the eigenvalues
$e_\pm=\tfrac12(1\pm j)$ the two non-trivial idempotents
$p_q(X)=X^2-2tX+q\bar q$ the characteristic polynomial
$b^2=\operatorname{disc}p_q/4$ the spectral condition
$\mathcal{N}=\{q\bar q=0\}$ the null cone, the two null lines
$\mathcal{S}=\{b=0\}$ the spectral-degenerate line, the real axis
$\Sigma_{ij}$ the sector with norm $i$ and spectrum $j$
$m_q$ the minimal polynomial

Further Reading