Reflections as Signed Two-Sided Operators on a Ring

Introduction

Among the signed two-sided operators of a graded ring, the ones of order two have a special place: they are the reflections. If $A$ carries a grade involution $\alpha$ and $u$ is invertible, the signed inner conjugation $$r_u(x) = u\,\alpha(x)\,u^{-1}$$ is an automorphism of $A$ for every invertible $u$, and it is an involution precisely when $u\alpha(u)$ is central. This article studies the reflections as a class: the correspondence between a reflection and the unit that defines it, the subgroup and coset structure they carry inside $\operatorname{Aut}(A)$, the criterion that singles out the involutive ones, and the degenerate cases in which the correspondence fails.

A reflection is not a new kind of operator — it is the diagonal signed two-sided operator $\mathcal{T}^{\alpha}_{u,u^{-1}} = \operatorname{conj}_u\circ\alpha$ of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Ring — but it is the one class of two-sided operators that acts on the elements as an automorphism of order two, and it is the algebraic skeleton of the geometric reflection of a quadratic space. That geometric reading requires forms and belongs to Part II and Part VI; nothing here measures an angle, a length or a distance, and "reflection" is a purely operator-theoretic name for an order-two automorphism of this shape.

Throughout, $A$ is a ring with $1 \neq 0$, not assumed commutative; $\alpha$ is a grade involution, $\alpha^2 = \mathrm{id}$; $A^\times$ and $Z(A)$ are the group of invertibles and the centre; $\operatorname{conj}_u(x) = uxu^{-1}$ is the inner automorphism; and $r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u\circ\alpha$ is the reflection by the unit $u$. The set-theoretic and coset facts about $\operatorname{Inn}(A)$ are from Inner Automorphisms of a Ring.

Reflections as Operators

The reflection by an invertible element

Definition. Let $u \in A^\times$. The reflection by $u$ is the operator

$$ r_u : A \to A, \qquad r_u(x) = u\,\alpha(x)\,u^{-1} . $$

It is the signed inner conjugation of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Ring, the diagonal signed two-sided operator $\mathcal{T}^{\alpha}_{u,u^{-1}}$.

Proposition. For every invertible $u$, $r_u$ is a unital ring automorphism of $A$, equal to the composite

$$ r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u \circ \alpha = \alpha \circ \operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(u)}, $$

with inverse $r_u^{-1} = r_{\alpha(u)^{-1}}$; and for all units $u, v$,

$$ \boxed{\;r_u \circ r_v = \operatorname{conj}_{u\,\alpha(v)}, \qquad r_u = r_v \iff uv^{-1} \in Z(A)\;}. $$

Proof. $r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u\alpha$ is a composite of automorphisms, hence an automorphism. The identity $\operatorname{conj}_u\alpha = \alpha\operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(u)}$ is $\alpha\operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(u)}(x) = \alpha(\alpha(u)x\alpha(u)^{-1}) = u\alpha(x)u^{-1}$. The inverse: $\alpha\operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(u)}$ composed with $\alpha\operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(u)^{-1}}$... equivalently $r_u r_{\alpha(u)^{-1}}(x) = u\alpha(\alpha(u)^{-1}\alpha(x)\alpha(u))u^{-1} = u\alpha(\alpha(u)^{-1})x\alpha(\alpha(u))u^{-1} = u\alpha(u)^{-1}x\alpha(u)u^{-1} = x$. For the product, $r_ur_v = \operatorname{conj}_u\alpha\operatorname{conj}_v\alpha = \operatorname{conj}_u\operatorname{conj}_{\alpha(v)}\alpha^2 = \operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(v)}$. Finally $r_u=r_v \iff \operatorname{conj}_u = \operatorname{conj}_v$, and that holds exactly when $uv^{-1}\in Z(A)$.

Corollary. The assignment $u \mapsto r_u$ is a well-defined injective map $A^\times/Z(A)^\times \to \operatorname{Aut}(A)$ whose image is the coset $\operatorname{Inn}(A)\,\alpha$ of the subgroup $\operatorname{Inn}(A)$ generated with $\alpha$: the reflections are the elements of $\operatorname{Aut}(A)$ of the form (an inner automorphism)$\circ\alpha$. In particular, the number of distinct reflections equals the order of the inner automorphism group at the invertibles, $|A^\times / Z(A)^\times|$.

Remark. The reflections do not form a subgroup of $\operatorname{Aut}(A)$: the product of two of them is the inner automorphism $\operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(v)}$, not a reflection, by the proposition. They form a coset of $\operatorname{Inn}(A)$ in the subgroup generated by $\operatorname{Inn}(A)$ and $\alpha$, so a reflection composed with a reflection is never a reflection (unless $\operatorname{Inn}(A)$ is trivial).

When a Reflection is an Involution

The criterion

Theorem (the order-two criterion). Let $u \in A^\times$. The reflection $r_u$ is an involution, $r_u^2 = \mathrm{id}$, if and only if

$$ \boxed{\;u\,\alpha(u) \in Z(A)\;}. $$

When this holds, $r_u$ is the inner automorphism $\operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(u)}$ of order two.

Proof. From the product formula, $r_u^2 = r_u r_u = \operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(u)}$, and an inner automorphism is the identity exactly when its conjugating element is central, by Inner Automorphisms of a Ring. Hence $r_u^2 = \mathrm{id} \iff u\alpha(u) \in Z(A)$.

Corollary. If $u$ is fixed by $\alpha$ then $u\alpha(u) = u^2$ and $r_u$ is an involution exactly when $u^2$ is central; if $u$ is negated by $\alpha$ and $2$ is invertible then $u\alpha(u) = -u^2$, again central exactly when $u^2$ is central. In both parities the criterion reduces to $u^2 \in Z(A)$.

The correspondence with the elements

The criterion organises the invertibles into those that act by an involution and those that act by an automorphism of larger order.

Definition. an invertible element $u$ is a reflecting element of $(A,\alpha)$ when $u\alpha(u) \in Z(A)$; equivalently, when the reflection $r_u$ is an involution.

Proposition. The reflecting elements form a subgroup $A^\times_{\mathrm{refl}}$ of $A^\times$ containing $Z(A)^\times$, and the map $u \mapsto r_u$ induces a bijection

$$ \boxed{\;A^\times_{\mathrm{refl}} / Z(A)^\times \;\longrightarrow\; \{\text{involutive reflections}\}\;}, $$

so the involutive reflections are in bijection with the reflecting units modulo the centre. The larger set of all reflections is in bijection with $A^\times/Z(A)^\times$.

Proof. If $u\alpha(u)$ and $v\alpha(v)$ are central, then $(uv)\alpha(uv) = u v \alpha(u)\alpha(v) = u\alpha(u)\,v\alpha(v)$ is central, since $\alpha$ is a homomorphism and central elements commute; and $u^{-1}\alpha(u^{-1}) = (u\alpha(u))^{-1}$ is central. So the reflecting elements form a subgroup, and the bijection is the restriction of the map of the proposition above, whose kernel is $Z(A)^\times$.

Example. In $A = M_2(k)$ with $J = \operatorname{diag}(1,-1)$ and $\alpha = \operatorname{conj}_J$, the unit $u = E_{12} + E_{21}$ has $\alpha(u) = -u$ and $u\alpha(u) = -u^2 = -I$, which is central; so $u$ is a reflecting element and $r_u$ is an involution. The unit $I + E_{12}$ acts by $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$, and $(I+E_{12})^2 = I + 2E_{12}$ is not central, so it is not a reflecting element and $r_{I+E_{12}} = \operatorname{conj}_{I+E_{12}}$ has infinite order in characteristic $0$.

Degenerate Cases

Non-Invertibles

The construction uses $u^{-1}$, and the criterion uses $u\alpha(u)$. If $u$ is a zero divisor the operator $x \mapsto u\alpha(x)u^{-1}$ is not defined, and the multiplication $x \mapsto u\alpha(x)$ alone is the signed left multiplication of The Signed Left Multiplication on a Ring, not a reflection. The correspondence between reflections and elements therefore has domain the invertibles, and it does not extend to the zero divisors.

Non-central $u\alpha(u)$

If $u$ is invertible but $u\alpha(u) \notin Z(A)$, then $r_u$ is an automorphism and not an involution: its square is the nontrivial inner automorphism $\operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(u)}$, and $r_u$ has infinite order in characteristic $0$ as soon as some power of $u\alpha(u)$ is non-central. The reflection exists — it is a signed two-sided operator, and $r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u\alpha$ — but it is not of order two, and the name "reflection" must then be carried only by the criterion and not by the operator.

The trivial grading

If $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$, every reflection is the inner conjugation $r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u$, and the criterion reads $u^2 \in Z(A)$; the involutive reflections are the self-inverse inner automorphisms. For a commutative ring $\operatorname{Inn}(A) = 1$, all reflections are the identity, and the class is degenerate. In characteristic $2$ the decomposition into even and odd parts fails, since $-1 = 1$ and the equation $\alpha(x) = -x$ is $\alpha(x) = x$; the only grade involution that is not the identity on the $p$-th-power structure is the Frobenius-related one of The Frobenius Operator on a Field of Characteristic p, and a reflection with $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$ is again an inner conjugation.

The fixed subring

Proposition. For an invertible element $u$, the fixed set of the reflection $r_u$ is the subring

$$ A^{r_u} = \{x \in A : \alpha(x) = \operatorname{conj}_{u^{-1}}(x)\}, $$

which contains the central even elements $Z(A) \cap A_{\bar 0}$.

Proof. The fixed set of an automorphism is a subring: if $r_u(x) = x$ and $r_u(y) = y$ then $r_u(x \pm y) = x \pm y$ and $r_u(xy) = xy$, and $r_u(1) = 1$. Rewriting $r_u(x) = x$ as $u\alpha(x)u^{-1} = x$ and multiplying by $u^{-1}$ on the left and $u$ on the right gives the displayed description. A central element $z$ with $\alpha(z) = z$ satisfies $\operatorname{conj}_{u^{-1}}(z) = z = \alpha(z)$, so it lies in $A^{r_u}$.

Summary

For a ring $A$ with grade involution $\alpha$ and an invertible element $u$, the reflection $r_u(x) = u\alpha(x)u^{-1}$ is the diagonal signed two-sided operator $\mathcal{T}^{\alpha}_{u,u^{-1}}$ and the composite $\operatorname{conj}_u\circ\alpha$; it is an automorphism with inverse $r_{\alpha(u)^{-1}}$, two reflections agree exactly when their units differ by a central unit, and the product of two reflections is the inner automorphism $\operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(v)}$. The reflections are therefore the coset $\operatorname{Inn}(A)\alpha$ inside the subgroup generated by the inner automorphisms and $\alpha$, indexed by $A^\times/Z(A)^\times$, and they do not form a subgroup.

The reflection $r_u$ is an involution exactly when $u\alpha(u)$ is central; the units satisfying this are the reflecting elements, they form a subgroup containing the centre, and the involutive reflections are in bijection with the reflecting elements modulo the centre. The correspondence fails at three points: non-invertibles are excluded because the construction needs $u^{-1}$; an invertible element with non-central $u\alpha(u)$ gives a reflection that is not of order two; and when $\alpha = \mathrm{id}$ (as in a commutative ring, or in characteristic $2$ with the trivial grading) the reflections collapse to the inner conjugations. The fixed set of a reflection is the subring where $\alpha$ and $\operatorname{conj}_{u^{-1}}$ agree. No form, length or angle is used; the geometric reflection of a quadratic space is a Part II and Part VI reading of the same operator.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$A$, $\alpha$ Ring with $1 \neq 0$ and its grade involution, $\alpha^2 = \mathrm{id}$
$r_u(x) = u\alpha(x)u^{-1}$ Reflection by an invertible element $u$; the signed inner conjugation
$r_u = \operatorname{conj}_u\circ\alpha = \mathcal{T}^{\alpha}_{u,u^{-1}}$ The reflection as an inner automorphism composed with $\alpha$
$r_ur_v = \operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(v)}$ Product of two reflections is inner
$r_u = r_v \iff uv^{-1} \in Z(A)$ Reflections indexed by $A^\times/Z(A)^\times$
$\operatorname{Inn}(A)\alpha$ The reflections as a coset of the inner automorphism group
$r_u^2 = \operatorname{conj}_{u\alpha(u)}$ Square of a reflection
$u\alpha(u) \in Z(A)$ Criterion for $r_u$ to be an involution
$A^\times_{\mathrm{refl}}$ Reflecting elements: units with $u\alpha(u)$ central
$\{x : \alpha(x) = \operatorname{conj}_{u^{-1}}(x)\}$ Fixed set of the reflection $r_u$

Further Reading

  • Ian R. Porteous, Clifford Algebras and the Classical Groups, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics 50 (Cambridge University Press, 1995), for the reflection of a vector space as a signed inner conjugation and its relation to the group of invertibles.
  • Pertti Lounesto, Clifford Algebras and Spinors, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 286 (Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed. 2001), for reflections, their inverses and the parity sign.
  • Max-Albert Knus, Alexander Merkurjev, Markus Rost and Jean-Pierre Tignol, The Book of Involutions, American Mathematical Society Colloquium Publications 44 (1998), for the involutions of a ring and the automorphisms of order two they define.
  • Israel Nathan Herstein, Noncommutative Rings (Mathematical Association of America, 1968), for inner automorphisms of order two and the centrality of the conjugating element.