Reflections as Signed Two-Sided Operators on a Graded Algebra

Introduction

A reflection of a graded algebra $A$ is a two-sided operator of order two, and the signed two-sided operators $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}(x)=a\alpha(x)b$ of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Graded Algebra supply the natural family of such operators: the signed two-sided operator $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$ is an involution exactly when $a\,\alpha(a)=1$, and this is the algebraic form of a reflection. This article reads the reflections of the graded algebra as signed two-sided operators, establishes the correspondence between the reflections and the elements $a$ with $a\alpha(a)=1$, measures how far the correspondence is from injective, and separates the nondegenerate cases, in which the correspondence holds, from the degenerate cases, in which a signed two-sided operator fails to be a reflection at all. The graded algebra and the grade involution are Superalgebras and Graded Structures; the two-sided operators and their composition law are The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Graded Algebra, cited throughout; the adjoint of a reflection is deferred to the - * Operator Theory group, and the geometric reflections of a quadratic space, which are the model, belong to the symmetric algebras.

The base is a commutative ring $R$ with $1$, $A=A^0\oplus A^1$ is a $\mathbb{Z}/2$-graded associative algebra with grade involution $\alpha$, and the operators are written $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}$ and $\Sigma_{a,b}$. The article reasons with the ring structure and the grading only.

Reflections and Their Two Kinds

Definition. An operator $S:A\to A$ is a reflection when $S\circ S=\mathrm{id}_A$. A reflection is signed when it is a signed two-sided operator, and unsigned when it is an unsigned two-sided operator.

Proposition. The grade involution $\alpha=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{1,1}$ is a signed reflection; the inner conjugation $\Sigma_{a,a^{-1}}(x)=axa^{-1}$, defined for an invertible element $a$, is an automorphism, and it is a reflection exactly when $a^{2}$ is central and $a^{-1}$ acts as $a$ in the conjugation, that is when $\Sigma_{a^{-1},a}=\Sigma_{a,a^{-1}}$.

Proof. $\alpha^2=\mathrm{id}$ by definition. The inner conjugation is an automorphism because it is conjugation by an invertible element; it is an involution exactly when conjugating by $a$ and by $a^{-1}$ agree, which is the displayed condition.

Corollary. The signed reflections and the unsigned reflections are two different families: the first carry the twist of the argument, the second do not, and they meet in the elements fixed by $\alpha$, that is in the even part when the even elements are the only ones used.

The Correspondence

Theorem. Let $\mathrm{R}(A)$ be the set of invertibles $a$ with $a\,\alpha(a)=1$ and let $\mathrm{Ref}^{\alpha}(A)$ be the set of signed two-sided operators that are reflections. The map

$$ \Phi:\mathrm{R}(A)\longrightarrow\mathrm{Ref}^{\alpha}(A),\qquad \Phi(a)=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,\,a^{-1}}, $$

is well defined, and its image consists of reflections whose square is the identity:

$$ \boxed{\;\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}\circ\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}=\mathrm{id}\;} . $$

Proof. The reflection property is the theorem of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Graded Algebra; the computation is $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}\circ\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a\alpha(a),\,\alpha(a^{-1})a^{-1}}=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{1,1}$.

Theorem (injectivity up to the centre). Two elements $a,c\in\mathrm{R}(A)$ give the same reflection if and only if $c^{-1}a$ lies in the centre of $A$; consequently the correspondence is injective on $\mathrm{R}(A)/\mathrm{Z}(A)^{\times}$.

Proof. $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{c,c^{-1}}$ means $a\alpha(x)a^{-1}=c\alpha(x)c^{-1}$ for every $x$, equivalently $(c^{-1}a)\alpha(x)=\alpha(x)(c^{-1}a)$ for every $x$; since $\alpha$ is a bijection the condition is that $c^{-1}a$ commutes with every element, which is centrality.

Corollary. The correspondence is a bijection onto its image when the centre is trivial; the signed reflection $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$ depends only on the class of $a$ modulo central units, exactly as the inner conjugation depends only on $a$ modulo central units.

Proposition (composition). The composite of two signed reflections is a signed two-sided operator of the same shape,

$$ \boxed{\;\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}\circ\Sigma^{\alpha}_{b,b^{-1}}=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{c,\,c^{-1}},\qquad c=a\,\alpha(b)\;}, $$

so the signed reflections generate the group of the operators $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$; the composite need not be an involution, and it is one exactly when $c\alpha(c)=1$.

Proof. The composition law of The Signed Two-Sided Operator on a Graded Algebra gives $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a\alpha(b),\,\alpha(b^{-1})a^{-1}}$, and $\alpha(b^{-1})a^{-1}=(a\alpha(b))^{-1}$ because $b\in\mathrm{R}(A)$; the composite is an involution exactly when $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{c,c^{-1}}$ is one, which by the reflection theorem of the previous section is the condition $c\alpha(c)=1$.

The Degenerate Cases

Definition. The correspondence is nondegenerate at $a$ when $a$ is invertible with $a\alpha(a)=1$; it is degenerate when $a\alpha(a)$ is a non-invertible, and totally degenerate when $a\alpha(a)=0$.

Theorem. The map $\Phi$ fails to be a correspondence in the degenerate cases: if $a\alpha(a)\neq1$ then $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$ is not a reflection, and if $a\alpha(a)=0$ then

$$ \boxed{\;\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}\circ\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}=0\;} , $$

so the operator is nilpotent of order two and not invertible.

Proof. The square is $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a\alpha(a),\,\alpha(a^{-1})a^{-1}}$ by the composition law; if the product is not the unit the square is not the identity; if $a\alpha(a)=0$ the square is the zero operator.

Corollary. In the exterior algebra $\Lambda^\bullet V$ an odd element $v$ satisfies $\alpha(v)=-v$, so $v\alpha(v)=-v\wedge v=0$: the signed two-sided operator $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{v,v^{-1}}$ is defined only if $v$ is invertible, which never happens for a nonzero odd element because $v^2=0$; this is the totally degenerate case, and it is why the reflections of the geometric theory need a Clifford algebra, where an odd element can be an invertible element. The Clifford algebra and its orthogonal group are the model of the symmetric algebras, and nothing of them is used here.

Remark. The failure is not a defect of the correspondence but a genuine change of type: as long as the base ring has zero divisors or the graded algebra has nilpotent odd elements, the signed two-sided operators of order two exhaust a strictly smaller set of reflections than the invertible ones, and the degenerate two-sided operators form a nilpotent family. This is the algebraic statement that a geometric reflection needs a non-isotropic vector.

Worked Case: The Even Part and the Odd Part

Let $A=A^0\oplus A^1$ be a graded algebra in which some odd element $u$ is invertible with $u\alpha(u)=1$; then $u^2=1$? Not necessarily: $u\alpha(u)=1$ reads $u\cdot(-u)=-u^2=1$ when $u$ is odd, so $u^{2}=-1$ in characteristic not two. Thus an odd signed reflection is an element whose square is $-1$, and the reflection it defines is $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{u,u^{-1}}(x)=u\alpha(x)u^{-1}$, which is the negative of the unsigned conjugation $uxu^{-1}$ on the odd part and equal to it on the even part. For the exterior algebra of a two-dimensional space there is no such odd unit, and every odd signed two-sided operator is totally degenerate; for a graded algebra in which the odd part is generated by elements of square $-1$, the odd signed reflections exist and are in bijection with the odd units modulo the centre.

Summary

A reflection of a graded algebra is an order-two two-sided operator. The signed reflections are the signed two-sided operators $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}(x)=a\alpha(x)a^{-1}$, and they are reflections exactly when $a\,\alpha(a)=1$; the grade involution itself is $\Sigma^{\alpha}_{1,1}$, and the unsigned inner conjugation is the other kind of reflection. The map $\Phi(a)=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$ from the invertibles with $a\alpha(a)=1$ to the signed reflections is well defined and injective modulo central units, its image is closed under composition in the sense that the product of two signed reflections is again a signed two-sided operator of the same shape with $c=a\alpha(b)$, and the product is an involution only under the stated centrality condition. In the degenerate cases the correspondence fails: an element with $a\alpha(a)$ a non-invertible gives a non-reflection, an element with $a\alpha(a)=0$ gives a square-zero operator, and in the exterior algebra every nonzero odd element is totally degenerate because $v^2=0$, so the geometric reflections require a Clifford algebra, which is the model of the symmetric algebras and is not used here.

Summary of Notation

Symbol Meaning
$R$ the commutative base ring, $K$ when units are needed
$A=A^0\oplus A^1$ a $\mathbb{Z}/2$-graded associative algebra
$\alpha$ the grade involution
$\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,b}(x)=a\alpha(x)b$ the signed two-sided operator
$\Sigma_{a,b}(x)=axb$ the unsigned two-sided operator
$\mathrm{R}(A)=\{a\text{ invertible}:a\alpha(a)=1\}$ the elements defining signed reflections
$\Phi(a)=\Sigma^{\alpha}_{a,a^{-1}}$ the correspondence to the signed reflections
$\mathrm{Z}(A)$ the centre

Further Reading

  • Nicolas Bourbaki, Algebra I, Chapters 1–3 (Springer, 1989), for graded algebras and their operators.
  • Ian R. Porteous, Clifford Algebras and the Classical Groups (Cambridge University Press, 1995), for reflections as signed conjugations.
  • H. Blaine Lawson and Marie-Louise Michelsohn, Spin Geometry (Princeton University Press, 1989), for the generation of orthogonal transformations by reflections.
  • Larry C. Grove, Classical Groups and Geometric Algebra, Graduate Studies in Mathematics 39 (American Mathematical Society, 2002), for the reflection correspondence in the geometric model.