From the Spin Group to the Spin of a Single Rotor: the Sign after $2\pi$ and the Return after $4\pi$

Introduction

The subject. A rotor is an element of the spin group, a single exponential of a generator, and its action on the module of the operators shows the two-turn phenomenon: after a full rotation the module is multiplied by minus one, and after two full rotations it returns. The article follows one rotor along a curve of the group, computes the holonomy, identifies where the sign lives, and reads the two covers that the group carries.

The order of the article. The rotor and its action come first; the sign after a full turn second. The return after two turns follows, then the two covers, and the holonomy closes the article.

It assumes The Spin Group: the Principal Copy, $\operatorname{Sym}^{3}$ and the Kernel $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$, The Four Weights of the Module and the Half Angle and The One-Sided Operators. The row of the elements is where a rotor turns a vector of space; here it turns an operator, and the operator sees the sign.

The result in one line. A rotor $u(\theta)=\exp(\theta\xi/2)$ acts on the module as a rotation of angle $\theta$ in the weight basis, the module changes sign at $\theta=2\pi$ and returns at $\theta=4\pi$, the algebra is unchanged at both, and the sign is a property of the module alone.

Boundaries. The weights themselves are The Four Weights of the Module and the Half Angle; the kernel is The Spin Group: the Principal Copy, $\operatorname{Sym}^{3}$ and the Kernel $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$; the covers of the rotation group are The Two Pin Groups and the Double Covers of the Orthogonal Group with Inner Conjugation.

The Rotor

Definition. For a real unit vector $\vec n$ of the vector part, the rotor of angle $\theta$ about $\vec n$ is $$ u(\theta)=\exp\!\left(\tfrac{\theta}{2}\,\xi_{\vec n}\right),\qquad \xi_{\vec n}=\vec n_x\xi_x+\vec n_y\xi_y+\vec n_z\xi_z, $$ the exponential taken in the operator algebra.

Theorem. The rotor is periodic, $u(\theta+4\pi)=u(\theta)$, and $u(\theta+2\pi)=-u(\theta)$. It acts on the module by the diagonal operator with the eigenvalues $e^{i(\theta/2)m}$ on the weight $m$, $$ u(\theta)\cdot v_m=e^{\,i\theta m/2}\,v_m,\qquad m=\tfrac32,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac32 . $$

Proof. The generator $\xi_{\vec n}$ has the four weights $2m$ on the module, by the definition of the weights; the exponential multiplies the weight vector $v_m$ by the exponential of $i\theta m$. Periodicity follows because the four values $e^{i\pi m}$ at $\theta=2\pi$ are the four signs of the half-integers, all of which are minus one.

Corollary. At $\theta=2\pi$ the module is multiplied by $-1$, and at $\theta=4\pi$ by $+1$.

Proof. $e^{2\pi i m}=(-1)^{2m}=-1$ for a half-integer $m$, and $e^{4\pi i m}=1$.

Corollary. The algebra, under the conjugation action of the same rotor, is unchanged at $\theta=2\pi$ and at $\theta=4\pi$.

Proof. Conjugation by a scalar is the identity, and the two values of the rotor at those angles are central.

The reading. One rotor, two behaviours: the module doubles back, the algebra does not. The reason is the half-integer weight, which is the label of the module and not of the algebra.

The Sign after a Full Turn

Proposition. The element $-\mathrm I$ of the group is the rotor of angle $2\pi$, and it acts as minus the identity on the module and as the identity on the algebra.

Proof. The rotor of angle $2\pi$ is the exponential of $\pi\xi_{\vec n}$, which equals the central element $-1$ for every unit $\vec n$; its left action is minus the identity, and its conjugation action is trivial.

Corollary. The sign after a full turn is independent of the axis, and it is the same for every rotor of angle $2\pi$.

Proof. All the rotors of angle $2\pi$ equal the same central element.

Corollary. No element of the algebra distinguishes the rotor of angle $2\pi$ from the identity, while every element of the module does.

Proof. The conjugation action is trivial on the algebra; the left action is minus the identity on the module.

The reading. The sign is not a defect of the construction: it is the difference between the two readings. An observer inside the algebra cannot detect the full turn; an observer inside the module sees a change of sign of the whole state.

The Return after Two Turns

Theorem. The map $\theta\mapsto u(\theta)$ from the circle of angle to the group is a double cover of the circle of rotations, and the module is a faithful module of the covering circle but not of the base.

Proof. The angle $\theta$ and the angle $\theta+2\pi$ give opposite elements of the group, and the two are the same rotation because conjugation by $-1$ is trivial; the module distinguishes the two, so it is faithful on the cover and not on the quotient.

Corollary. A closed curve of rotations lifts to a path of the group that closes only after two turns, and the holonomy of the lift is the sign.

Proof. The lift of the closed curve of rotations ends at the element $-1$ after one turn and at the identity after two.

Corollary. The module has no continuous choice of sign along a closed curve of rotations, and the ambiguity is measured by the first Stiefel–Whitney class of the projective quotient.

Proof. The two lifts differ by the sign, and the sign is the non-trivial class of the double cover.

The reading. The return after two turns is the statement that the group is a double cover and that the module is the space on which the cover acts faithfully. The two turns are not a curiosity of one example: they are forced by the half-integer label.

The Two Covers

Proposition. The group carries two quotients: the rotation group of the vector part, by the kernel $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$, and the projective quotient of the module, by the scalars.

Proof. The kernel of the module action is $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$, and the kernel of the action on the projective module is the full centre.

Corollary. The projection to the linear group of the module is a quotient by the scalars, and it is not the same quotient as the projection to the rotations.

Proof. The two kernels are different: one of order two, the other the circle of scalars intersected with the group.

Corollary. A single rotor is an element of the group, and its projective class is what the module of states remembers.

Proof. The module is defined up to scalars in the projective reading, and the rotor acts on the classes.

The reading. Two covers, one kernel each. The rotation group is the base of the first, the projective linear group the base of the second, and a rotor sits in the group above both. The sign after a full turn is the statement that the first cover is non-trivial; the return after two turns is the statement that its total space is connected.

The Holonomy

Definition. For a curve $\gamma$ in the rotation group with a chosen base point, the holonomy is the element of the group that the lift of $\gamma$ produces at the end.

Proposition. The holonomy of a closed curve of rotations is $\pm1$, and it is $-1$ exactly when the curve is the projection of a path joining the two lifts of one point.

Proof. The lift is unique once a starting point is chosen, and the two possible ends differ by the sign; the sign is $-1$ exactly when the lift does not close.

Corollary. The holonomy depends only on the homotopy class of the curve, and it defines a homomorphism from the fundamental group of the rotation group to $\{\pm1\}$.

Proof. The lift depends only on the homotopy class, and the endpoint is a sign.

Corollary. The non-trivial loop of the rotation group has holonomy $-1$, and it is the loop that a rotor of angle $2\pi$ projects to.

Proof. The rotor of angle $2\pi$ is the lift of the trivial loop based at the identity, ending at $-1$.

The reading. The holonomy is the group-theoretic form of the sign: a closed path in the base, a sign in the fibre. The algebra sees the base, the module sees the fibre, and the two readings are the two ends of one covering.

Further Reading